After reading the reviews on this (I had already purchased it), I thought I would give it a whirl as an eye brightener. Let me tell you, I love it! I love the look of white eyeliner in the inner corners of the eyes and also the inner rims, but it is true that sometimes it looks too harsh. This is the perfect color to get that same look but without the harshness. I have been using it for the sole purpose of an eyeliner since I read the reviews! I like it as a lipliner yes but I'm just not the biggest lip liner gal...I don't think about it so I don't remember it in the routine I guess, although I do like it. Odd I know. Anyway, I bought this because I was trying to ease myself into lip liner, just trying it out. I absolutely despise the dark ring around the lips look, so this pencil does well defining the perimeter of the lips and keeping glosses and lipsticks from migrating. But without the appearance of a normal lipliner. It really is a very versatile little stick, also works well as a spot concealor and it covers the dreaded lip perimeter zit (horror!) that can occur on occasion (those are the devil). It has excellent staying power as well. Very pleased overall with this product, although the actual reason I bought it for turned out to be what I rarely use it for. Go figure.