Urban Decay

I absolutely love this pencil. It stays on my waterline all day and does not collect in my inner corners. It glides so smooth and there is no tugging at all. I will definitely buy this again. I would give it five stars, but I prefer a automatic liner better and the pencil is pretty thick and is hard to make smaller lines.

I layered this on with my Benefit Roller Lash and I have to agree with everyone else - it's a very wet mascara that adds mostly volume with some length. The brush is the most interesting thing, because it's very soft and plush, whereas most mascara wands are a thick plastic with rigid combs or toothing. Definitely a nice mascara regardless, no smudging for this oily-lidded gal!

So many mascaras smudge and flake on me that at this point, anything that stays on my lashes is getting at least 4 stars. That being said, I do like this mascara especially when it's on sale. The best part about it is definitely that on me it doesn't smudge or flake when seemingly everything else does. It's very black, definitely more of a volumizing than lengthening mascara, and goes on pretty wet. On me it doesn't give a super dramatic look. It can get a little clumpy and I wish that it had a bolder effect but overall, I'll probably keep buying it.