I've never spent this much on lipstick, it's $18 normally, but Beauty.com had an anniversary & anything you bought was 20% off, so I went for it. I bought it in Cupcake. It's a lovely, bright pink - not a dark color, but not light so that it's pale really, it's more traditional pink. I love the formula, it's smooth, it has a faint yet lovely scent, & it stays on forever. I like to put on a thin coat of clear base before I put a lipstick on so that lipsticks feel comfortable, so I don't know if this is drying on it's own. The container is beautiful & sleek. The only reason it's 4 instead of 5 lippies is 1) the price (oof) & 2) I have to be gentle using it because any hard pressing would in time dislodge the lipstick at it's base. That probably sounds like a real downer, but I love the other qualities SO much that I just don't care, I'll work around it. The shade suits my extremely fair/porcelain pink-toned skin, and works just fine over my heavily pigmented lips. This is not a natural or subtle pink, it's girly, and leaning towards bold, but not garish or loud. I'll definitely re-purchase, I absolutely adore this thing. I'll consider trying the other two shades that *might* work on my very fair coloring, Totally Nude & Celebrity Meltdown, but I'd probably wait for another discount. My first Too Faced product - LOVE.
UPDATE: It's a year since I bought Cupcake & I just bought Marcia Marcia Marcia & Pink Flamingo. Both shades are great, I wrote a review on MMM already. Pink Flamingo is a pinky peach (very little pink, but the peach is definitely not the only shade there), with some glimmer to it, and looks great on my very fair skin/highly pigmented lips. I love these lipsticks! I usually apply over a moisturizing base and it makes the shade more subtle, which I tend to do with all my lipsticks. Fun stuff :)