Proof It Eyeshadow Primer

It's good but not great. It's almost transparent and provides a sticky base. As it is already mentioned you need to leave it dry for a couple of seconds and then set it with powder. I have oily hooded eyelids and my eyeshadow still creases after 5-6 hours with this primer. So, it extends the wear of my eyeshadow but doesn't prevent it from creasing.

This is a really good primer but it's slightly finicky which is why I give it 4 stars instead of 5. This is a white cream primer with a doe foot applicator. First off, when you apply this, LET IT DRY COMPLETELY BEFORE PUTTING EYESHADOW ON TOP!! This is a primer that needs to be totally dry or else you will have a skippy smudgy mess. But, if it is totally dry, it's really long …Read more

This is absolutely "the best" Eyeshadow Primer out there, bar none!

In one of my other recent primer reviews, I mentioned that the Tarte 360 Creaseless 12 Hour Eyeshadow Primer was my holy grail for a long time (but unfortunately it was discontinued), and that's when the NYX Proof It Eyeshadow Primer came into my life!!!

It's just the perfect …Read more

I've loved the Thank Me Later eyelid primer but now I'm sticking with NYX Proof it! Waterproof Eyelid Primer. Once applied, give it a couple of minutes to adhere, then I recommend a light dusting of powder prior to applying powder shadows, to keep it blendable.

This primer grabs products and lasts an amazingly long time on my extremely oily lids. Highly recommend as it is …Read more

This holds my eyeshadow on throughout the day without an issue. I don't love it, but I don't hate it. I feel like it goes on a little thick and can make my eyeshadow stick too much like it doesn't blend well. I try to use a thin layer, but it can be difficult with how goopy and wet this stuff is. I appreciate the doe-foot applicator so I don't have primer all over my fingers …Read more

I was already in love with the NYX HD Primer so I gave this one a shot. I think this one is even better. I work in a warehouse and do lots of heavy lifting everyday and this stuff helped my eyeshadow stay put through the sweating. I still saw a lot of shimmer on my eyelids after an 8 hour day, which is awesome!

Compared to the HD primer, this one is stickier, which is probably why it …Read more

4.5 stars! Bang for your buck!

I don’t wear makeup as often as I used to and so long are the days of heavy makeup for a night out. My main concern now is just to make sure my eyeliner stays put during the day. I used to only swear by the Urban Decay eye Primer Potion when it was in the original long genie bottle wand packaging, but since then, I felt like the formula just wasn’t the …Read more

I've been wearing this every day for a little over a week now and I'm honestly pretty disappointed. I thought with its waterproof claims, that it would be long-wearing and prevent my shadows from creasing. So far, used with different eyeshadows, cream and powder, my eyeshadows will start creasing after just 4 hours. I was hoping it would be a good drugstore option for some of the more …Read more

To be honest this is one of the few eyeshadow primers I've used, but it's so good I haven't felt the need to look for others. Keeps the eyeshadow from creasing very well and makes it last all day and night, which is the main thing I'm looking for in a primer. Has a light nude tint in it, so helps to cover any discoloration you might have in your eyelids.
Leaves a bit …Read more

Let me begin by saying that I use mostly higher end eyeshadows and when I don't use this primer, with time even they tend to crease. This eyeshadow primer is great for ensuring the longevity and smoothness of eyeshadows, it prevents any creasing for me and makes them actually pretty much waterproof, for what I've noticed. I always set it with light/my skin tone of eyeshadow. It's …Read more