24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil - Rockstar

I love the color of this eyeliner; it's a perfect dark-ish plum. It glides on so smoothly and is so easy to apply. It also doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes. However, it smudges way too quickly for me and doesn't last long. I won't be buying again. Update: I decided to keep trying this liner because I love the color so much and it's so creamy and smooth when I apply it. If I use primer and set the primer with shadow, and then apply the liner, and then go over it with a similar shadow on an eyeliner brush, it lasts most of the day. I will repurchase.

This is my go-to eyeliner. I've been using it for years, and always have an extra on hand. I love how smoothly it applies, and it lasts all day on my lids. I have to use makeup remover to get it off at bedtime. Best thing about it is the gorgeous, eggplant colour - it really makes my blue/green eyes pop! I use it with my Urban Decay Basics 2 palette for my everyday, work look. It is a bit pricey compared to drugstore liners (I purchase mine at Shoppers Drug Mart in Canada) but, in this case, you get what you pay for. Will definitely be repurchasing this as long as they make it.

My HG eye pencil and best I've found for hazel eyes

The color of this pencil is indeed very beautiful for hazel or light brown eyes. Far better than usual black eyeliner. The problem that I have with this pencil is a texture. It's way too smooth. You can't draw really thin line with it, even if you somehow manage to sharpen it for precise application it will get thicker by every millimeter down the line. I have hooded eyes, I need precision, I need pencil that is capable of drawing thin lines. It also smudges easily, and color doesn't stay intense from morning till evening. It seriously fades through the day. However I find that removal of what is left tricky, it doesn't want to leave my eyes completely no matter what product I try. Disappointed.

This eye pencil is a slightly darker purple. I was expecting an eggplant colour, but on my warm fair-medium skin with yellow undertones it comes out slightly darker. Nevertheless, this product is famous and for good reasons. It applies easily and is creamy, and is fairly lasting. However, the pencil really requires setting with eyeshadow/powder. I have hooded eyes, and I get "stamps" by eye pencils at the top lid. But, with eyeshadow, the liner does stay on. The price is unfriendly though, and I'm on the hunt for a dupe pencil liner that is half the price...

I'm not sure what all the fuss is about. I bought this because I have green eyes and I'm always on the lookout for purple eyeliners that will enhance my colouring while still being fairly subtle. The reviews for Rockstar all say that it makes green or hazel eyes pop. Well, I don't see it. On me this looks like a dull, washed-out black. It doesn't read purple or eggplant at all. There's nothing wrong with it but nothing special either, and certainly not worth the price tag. Like all UD eyeliners, it goes on fairly easily and is decent quality. However, the colour is just not special enough for me.

i love these 24/7 pencils so much. they are creamy, pigmented and excellent on my waterline. i love trying new colours too. rockstar is my current favourite because of the standout quality and colour. it is a deep eggplant purple that is a nice alternative to black or brown. i used to be a black-eyeliner-only kind of girl but these types of colours are so flattering and pretty on, while still giving either dramatic or natural definition. the price is a little steep for a pencil liner but i will buy this colour again because i love the look it gives my deep brown eyes.

I got this from Amazon :) I have the color binge it's a pretty shimmer purple. It sharpens to a nice point and goes on smooth and is very pigmented. This is my first urban decay purchase. And I want to buy more when I see them on sale :)

I got this in a travel size, and I loved it so much that I've already almost used it up. This color is unique and looks great with every eye color. I have blue eyes and this really makes them pop. I wasn't sure I was going to like the eggplant color but it isn't garish at all an looks quite nice. This stuff is really easy to apply. It goes on so smooth, like butter. The only problem I have (and the reason why I took off a lippy) is that it isn't totally smudge-proof. When I apply it to my lower waterline, it's already moving around and giving my raccoon eyes within an hour or two. It makes me a little sad...I was hoping this would be the one. On my eyelid it lasts forever though, so no compliant there. This stuff is still awesome and beautifully pigmented, and I'll likely be repurchasing this color in the future.

I love this color. A nice deep eggplant. But I have oily lids and this stuff smudges every where!! I am surprised at the super high ratings. It is also very soft so it is easy to make a mistake and it isn't the easiest to fix