They're Real Lengthening Mascara

I bought this because I liked the brush shape and thought I would be able to get well defined non clumpy lashes. Works ok but SMUDGES. As in after an hour or two there is dark smear in lower lash line. I have other mascaras that never do this. Will not be buying again.

I had high hopes for fake looking lashes but unfortunately , it applied thinly just about darkening my lashes and provided no volume or length . Worst of all the plastic brush irritated by lash line and it is the worst mascara to remove . Talking industrial strength even with my Mac cleansing oil which normally breaks down everything including sunscreen and other waterproof mascaras . I think I …Read more

I was looking for a new mascara and read a few reviews to find the best one. This mascara had so many amazing reviews so I decided to give it a try and I don’t regret my decision. This is one fabulous mascara! I have eyelash extensions and have had no problems with this mascara. It makes my lashes feel so soft and it lasts all day. It doesn’t smudge and it’s so easy to remove with normal face …Read more

This wasn't the worst mascara I have used. I rarely dislike any mascara because I do have naturally long lashes, so a lot of mascara looks really nice on my lashes. This mascara was a little clumpy which I did not like but I do know some people do so I thought I should mention. The wand isn't small but it isn't big either its a nice size and is easy to get the inner lashes. It does …Read more

This is one of my favorite mascaras. I have trouble with mascaras smearing under my lower lash line-the dreaded "racoon eyes". This one NEVER does that! It really gives me great definition, lengthens and thickens. I actually have had compliments on my lashes when I wear this. It stays on all day and looks great all day. I have repurchased this many times. This and Lash Paradise …Read more

Got this in my Birchbox this month and am always excited to try new mascaras. This one is AWFUL!! It actually hurt to put it on, due to the brush and how it feels like barbed wire--especially if like me, you apply first at the lash base. The result was a couple coats of sloppy product all up in my eyelid and I looked like I had about 6 eyelashes on each side ! And here comes the WORST …Read more

Benefit They’re Real Mascara is the only true HG product I have. As in, cannot exist without it and nothing comes close. I have extremely oily skin / lids, the tiniest bit of hooded lids and very long, naturally curled lashes. All mascaras transfer to my crease, brow and brow bone without fail about 2 hours into my 12 hour day…except Benefit They’re Real. I’ve tried every drugstore brand …Read more

I love this mascara! Truly one of my HG products. The length it gives my lashes is unreal. I have long lashes but when I wear this it looks like i have false lashes on. It instantly elevates any look that I've got on. My eyes look bigger and I generally look more awake when I wear this. The ball at the end is perfect for separating and defining lashes. The only problem is that when the …Read more

I have to confess I got this mascara for free at a 'lucky dip' promotion Benefit was having in Sydney. Usually it costs $43AUD, which is quite pricey, so I usually stick to drugstore mascaras. But this is really good. This mascara definitely lengthens and separates the lashes, giving that 'false lash' effect. It also doesn't smudge or flake throughout the day, which is …Read more

This was my favorite mascara when I was using a sample size but somehow the full-size didn’t translate for me. Maybe it gets dry, but it applies clumpy and it needs a lot of work with the spooly to look presentable, and many layers Are required to get a thickening effect. I’m going to finish off the one in my make up bag and continue my search for my HG mascara.