NYC New York Color

They still have this, hadn't seen it for ages, it was my only liner since a teen before I realized my eyes were sensitive to the brush applicator... not every tube had an evenly cut brush. Quality control? If that happens, it just needs to be held a particular way (side and diagonally not straight on) throughout application...when one is in a rush that's not always on one's mind. Besides, most things hurt my eyes. They've always been extra sensitive, that's why I went through so many liners trying to find one that was tolerated. The formula itself is good. I think it's better than L'oreal's.. Nyc's brush is better than the brush version of L'oreal too. It works excellently all in all as most cheap cosmetics seem to do now. It doesn't bleed or smudge or have an odd finish, does not gunk on lashes, brush is sometimes poky (varies) but one can work around that considering the price. If you like a simple thin line this is great. I do run out of this faster than other brands so I can't figure out how that works out for value of money but still I would recommend this to anybody on a budget. Rimmel too.

This I've bought at least 4 times so far (edit to add 2 of those times I had to rebuy because the bad cap got off and lipstick smushed and broke, fell on ground) this colour. With a nudy liner and any gloss that can mute it a touch it works perfectly for a nice pop of colour. This brand is bad with the caps if only they fixed that. Easy favourite over the past couple of years. (note: colour may put off most people and register as tacky, a light application with a muted gloss works best)

I like this and the “Showtime curling” one. Really decent volume and length. Nice dark color payoff. No crumbles, just sort of fades if u sleep in it and lashes feel normal the next day, so i like it for long days/travel. Great brush and bottle (not like those huge clunky crappy ones, kwim?)