wet n wild Color Icon Brow & Eyeliner

I'm really, genuinely impressed by the quality of this eyeliner. Twelve years old entering the emo scene scouring Walmart for an eyeliner. Settled on the black one from Wet n' Wild, subsequently abused it for a couple months before leaving my phase behind, but not this eyeliner. It was soft, it was pigmented, and it was super long. I actually ran out several times despite its size from using it so much. Stays on all day unless you have oilier lids, otherwise it will smudge. Other than that I continued wearing this liner past my emo-kid days because it was so great and soft. Not hard and stiff or painful to apply at all.

Have multiples in taupe and other colors. Use on brows, eyes, occasionally lips. Taupe in combination with mink brown pencil on the brows with some elf brow gel makes a very finished sculpted brow. (I think the pencil helps the gel adhere). Some pencils seem to have a softer texture than others. For the price, they are great and last forever. I am NC 30-35, Asian, olive skin with deeply pigmented lips, cool undertones. I prefer cool toned taupe and this is perfect as it has ash undertones.

Note: recent reformulations (my beige nude and white pencils) are creamier and softer. Beige (called Call Your Buff) is a bit firmer and more yellow than NYX wonder pencil medium tone which tends to crumble, require more sharpening and smudge slightly more. I have uses for both brands. The nude color is nice to reinforce a strong crisp brow.

In general, IMO, sephora nano, rimmel and Milani seem to smudge more than WnW. But a bit of WnW eye primer helps with that.

These were some of my first eyeliners and I really can't use any other brand. I have the black, brown and white colour. The colour is intense enough and goes on very easy but yet it does not smudge quite as easily as other Kohl eyeliners. I use them for tight lining or water lining because of how easily they come off in those areas without hurting you and still lasts fairly long. They are very cheap as well and definitely worth their price. I bough so many other eyeliners after they stopped having them at Walmart here in canada and I just don't use those other eyeliners.

Best value for your money.

I have the brown one and I use it to line my eye lids smudging the product a little for a more natural finish.

It holds up pretty well.

This is one of my holy grails.

My hair has been jet black for the past year, so I've been using the black one for my brows. I never use it as eyeliner, ever. I love it to shape my brows, it stays on without smearing.

I cover it with Anastasia Beverly Hills brow pomade and they work beautiful together.

Recently, I've ombre'd my hair to brown to blonde, with most of it being blonde, so I needed to get a new wet n wild eyeliner

I purchased the color Taupe, for $0.78! It's basically free.

I love it for my new hair color. Now I have to order a new abh pomade, but I love changing my colors for my hair!

I'll buy this eyeliner (really a brow pencil) forever! I'll never change it. I've tried all of the expensive liners and this one takes allllll the cake honey.

These pencils are fantastic! I have one in dark brown and it has such a rich pigment. The formula is the best thing about these liners, as they're incredibly smooth and glide on effortlessly - something that even many high end pencil liners lack. I'd say in terms of ease of use, these liners are a dupe for my HG Too Faced Perfect Eyes liners - and at 1/18th of the cost! Love!

"Don't Leaf Me" eyeliner.
A beautiful almost blackened green with some shimmer. Lasts all day! Very, very pretty for the holidays.

I have bronzed . I live in the tropics and i bought them twice in my life . Ten years back I had one in black and it kept going soft and it was near impossible to sharpen . I bought one recently in bronzed and the quality has improved . The Color is a gorgeous golden brown and gives my brown eyes a nice pop and yet looks like a nude look . However I still find it a tad on the soft side , could be due to the tropics . But it's so super cheap for this lovely Color .

I have bought a whole bunch of these eyeliners over the years, even though I mostly use liquid eyeliners now...I buy these because they are cheap for a lot of product and they come in fun colors. So mostly I buy these if I'm feeling more experimental than my go-to black liquid liner, but don't want to splurge on a colored pencil I might not even like.

The pencil in particular that I just got--"Like, Comment, or Share"-- is new to the Wet N Wild color icon kohl eyeliner line. These look pretty much the same as the old ones, but they boast of a new, creamier formula. I do find that it is a bit creamier than my old wnw liners and do not tug on the lid (but this also means that the liner tends to crease up on me a little since I have oily lids).

Anyway, Like Comment or Share is a pretty true blue kind of eyeliner--not to be confused with the Deep Blue (a navy with green undertones) or the purple one (I think now it is called Of Quartz?..). This is just the color I have been looking for. A bright blue that is a noticeable pop of color but dark enough that it can be wearable for just being out and about, doing whatever. It doesn't seem that many people on the internet talk about this particular color of pencil, but it's a unique color for the drugstore. And I love it for the price! It was $.99 with 40% off wnw products at my Rite Aid. I also posted a picture for reference.

These are really iconic for me. I started buying these when I was in junior high school, along with the lip liners, of course. Can't beat 99 cents with a stick. I remember my older sisters would use the little red Maybelline brow pencils as eyeliner, and would soften them with lighters. Um, no thanks. Didn't have to soften these. They worked great as-is. And still do. They aren't the longest lasting eyeliners, but I like to augment them with eyeshadows which change the color and set them to last all day.