Jumbo Eye Pencil in Iced Mocha

I got this in the shade Yogurt too, and I tried to use them both as cream eyeshadows as a base all over the lid. (The colors are so pretty! Mocha is almost a taupe-like hue.) But they creased a ton throughout the day and by the evening I had white lines on my lids where the color had worn off.
Then I started using the Mocha shade as an eyeliner, and it performed beautifully! It's also …Read more

Pros: Pretty everyday colour that suits my fair (yellow undertone) skin. I'm the type of person who hates to do fancy eyeshadow and this pencil makes my eye shadow game strong without the time and fuss!

Cons: For those with oily lids, this might be too oily and you might want to use a primer.

Gorgeous neutral taupe/brown/purple color. Definitely need to use an eyeshadow primer before applying this product. I love using this as a base for my bronze or purple he shadows, especially with mac's satin taupe. "Iced mocha" makes my brown eyes pop. Definitely would repurchase!

Pretty color, however the formula is too oily. My eyelids are not oily so I thought I would give it a try. I have the milk crayon and it is not this oily, so I was surprised. They are are different.

These jumbo pencils are so affordable and come in a great variety of colours. Iced Mocha is a really pretty frosted taupe brown that is useful for so many neutral eye looks. I only ever use these as eye liners because even with a really decent eye primer they still have a tendency to crease badly. I have tried these with Too Faced Glitter Glue as an eye shadow and after a few hours it …Read more

NYX Iced Mocha, Y U do dis?! I wanted to love you so much. I was so happy when my local CVS started carrying NYX and even more happy when I saw they had you, Iced Mocha. Honestly, you are the most beautiful color I've ever seen. But why must you crease so much? :(
The first time I used this shadow pencil, I used no primer. Kind of a bad decision for someone with hooded, oily lids. Of …Read more

The pros: Availability and price are both great, but the color is best part about this -- a frosty bronzed medium taupey brown. Unfortunately that's where the pros end. This is so creamy that it's almost greasy. I tried it as both an eyeliner (smudged like no tomorrow and the smears were difficult to remove completely), and as shadow for a smoky eye - no staying power and smeared all …Read more

I use this product solely as an eyeliner. I LOVE the way it looks on my lower lash line! It gives me very soft, subtle definition that works wonderfully with my fair skin. It spreads easily and is VERY difficult to use too much and make your eyes look too intense, which is something I'm always paranoid about. I do, however, have 2 complaints about this product. My biggest issue is that it …Read more

Great subtle colour. Texture is smooth with decent pigmentation. It's a frostier finish and I think would make a good base for earthy toned/bronze eye shadows. Price ($5) and packaging are great as well. Not sure about repurchasing as I don't need this colour but it's good to have on hand, but def will buy other pencils from the same line to try out the different colours.

Iced Mocha, Strawberry Milk, and Yogurt are MUST HAVES. I do like the ideas of potting the product and freezing the pencils to sharpen them so they don't crumble. I love my Maybelline color tattoos but after seeing how easy an eye can be made up with a shadow stick or two, I decided to try these out, since I was actually able to use them before I got them. Late in the game because I like to …Read more