I bought this the other day because I saw it on a list that boasted the best eyeliners. Why this product was on that list, I'll never know. I looked up the reviews on here and I was debating on whether to just return the product or to open it. "You never know unless you try it out for yourself!" I told myself. That and the majority of my makeup consists of CoverGirl. Now, I wish I listened to you guys and just returned it. Terrible eyeliner. It doesn't go on smooth, it's splotchy and watery, and if it dries and you try to line your eye again? It wipes off. It was also almost ten dollars for me. Knowing what I know now, I wouldn't pick this up even if it were free. To feel less bad about the purchase, I use it as a kind of base while I go over it with my ELF eyeliner. Kind of funny how an eyeliner purchased from the dollar store would work better than one purchased at a department store.
TL;DR: This eyeliner sucks.