no images

3.5

Created with Sketch.
12 reviews
58%
would repurchase
3.5/5
package quality

price range

Reviews


3.0
Created with Sketch.

Mar/28/2018

I have this in the color graphite which is a charcoal black. The gel formula glides easily on the skin and is long lasting and non-irritating to my eyes. I have used the Mally Evercolor Starlight Waterproof eyeliner pencil for years and still prefer that formula to these automatic gel eyeliners because the Evercolor Starlight eyeliners last all day until I take them off. The gel eyeliners will …Read more

Is this review helpful?

About reviewer (3041 reviews)

Age44-55

SkinCombination, Fair, Cool

HairOther, Straight, Fine

EyesOther



5.0
Created with Sketch.
fromjmara

Dec/16/2014

I bought this wonderful eyeliner just yesterday in Sailor, I was looking for a navy shade. Compared with others, this shade seems to be more of a dark grey-blue and I absolutely
love it. It seems to stay on the entire day and goes on in either a thick or a thin line, depending on what I want. And the price is decent compared with some others I also tried before buying this …
Read more

Is this review helpful?

About reviewer (84 reviews)

Age56 & Over

SkinVery Dry, Fair, Cool

HairBlond, Straight, Fine

EyesBrown


4.0
Created with Sketch.

Jul/04/2014

The Mally Automatic Eyeliners are my absolute favorite! I've tried so many pencils, smudge-pots, you name it. I got these in a set last year and I got so much mileage out of them that I've only opened about half of them (maybe came with 10?), and I only opened half for some color variety.

Most of the time with eyeliners, I have to wear the blackest black, for lack of …
Read more

1 of 1 people found this helpful. Did you?

About reviewer (62 reviews)

Age36-43

SkinDry, Fair-Medium, Cool

HairBlond, Straight, Medium

EyesBlue


5.0
Created with Sketch.

Jun/16/2013

I received 3 of these liners in Mally's 14-piece mega kit waaaay back in November, and I still have tons of product left. I actually had to look back at my QVC orders to remember when I got the kit, and I was surprised as all get out that it was that long ago. It's a real shame that another reviewer's liners dried out, but mine are just as good as the day I got them …Read more

1 of 1 people found this helpful. Did you?

About reviewer (235 reviews)

Age36-43

SkinCombination, Fair, Cool

HairOther, Straight, Fine

EyesHazel


2.0
Created with Sketch.

Apr/20/2013

I think this would be a good choice if you use 1 eyeliner only daily and use it up fairly fast. I had one of these from a kit a year ago and without the wood or plastic around it tight like a pencil to keep the product from exposure to air, it dried up completely. I rolled it up & it was warped & dry. They are the same formulas as the pencil form and have 6 of those and have had no …Read more

Is this review helpful?

About reviewer (272 reviews)

Age44-55

SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Warm

HairBrunette, Wavy, Medium

EyesBrown


4.0
Created with Sketch.

Oct/28/2012

Pretty good, if you ask me. It's a quite pigmented eyeliner that doesn't tug, pull, or hurt when I use it to tightline or line my upper and lower lash line. I like the fact that it's automatic and retractable. However, the cap doesn't close all the way unless I REALLY push on it and secure it. It also smudges a bit, but not too badly.

2 of 2 people found this helpful. Did you?

About reviewer (58 reviews)

AgeUnder 18

SkinOily, Fair, Neutral

HairOther, Straight, Medium

EyesGray


3.0
Created with Sketch.

Jun/14/2012

These are just okay. I honestly think all Mally's eyeliners are the same and she just repackages them with a new name every year. I have her original automatic liners, her evercolor Starlight Waterproof liners in pencil form, and her latest eye liner in pencil form that doesnt have a particular name other than color. They all wear the exact same! Last quite well on top lash line and …Read more

Is this review helpful?

About reviewer (4641 reviews)

Age36-43

SkinAcne-prone, Olive, Not Sure

HairBrunette, Other, Other

EyesBrown


4.0
Created with Sketch.

Apr/09/2012

These are my favorite eyeliners. They glide on smooth and last all day, even in the hot summers with my oily eyelids...LOVE THEM!

1 of 1 people found this helpful. Did you?

About reviewer (16 reviews)

Age44-55

SkinOther, Other, Not Sure

HairOther, Other, Other

EyesOther


5.0
Created with Sketch.

Dec/30/2011

I have oily lids and I actually like these quite a bit. I do have to use a primer on my lids before application but I am able to achieve a thin line along the eyelash with no tugging. The colors are quite pigmented and though they do wear off a bit during the day I find myself reaching for an oil base cleanser to completely remove it at night.

Is this review helpful?

About reviewer (53 reviews)

Age25-29

SkinOther, Fair-Medium, Not Sure

HairBlack, Other, Other

EyesBrown


4.0
Created with Sketch.

Dec/18/2011

I don't normally use pencil eye liner because those I've used tend to scratch and smudge on me, so I stick to liquid eye liner. I tested the onyx on my mom who has the oiliest eye lids I have ever seen (eye liner smudges within moments!), but it held up pretty well. I also have a green and brown colors which are rather pretty.

1 of 1 people found this helpful. Did you?

About reviewer (30 reviews)

Age25-29

SkinVery Dry, Fair-Medium, Cool

HairBrunette, Wavy, Fine

EyesBrown