Evercolor Waterproof Automatic Eyeliner

I have this in the color graphite which is a charcoal black. The gel formula glides easily on the skin and is long lasting and non-irritating to my eyes. I have used the Mally Evercolor Starlight Waterproof eyeliner pencil for years and still prefer that formula to these automatic gel eyeliners because the Evercolor Starlight eyeliners last all day until I take them off. The gel eyeliners will …Read more

I bought this wonderful eyeliner just yesterday in Sailor, I was looking for a navy shade. Compared with others, this shade seems to be more of a dark grey-blue and I absolutely
love it. It seems to stay on the entire day and goes on in either a thick or a thin line, depending on what I want. And the price is decent compared with some others I also tried before buying this …Read more

The Mally Automatic Eyeliners are my absolute favorite! I've tried so many pencils, smudge-pots, you name it. I got these in a set last year and I got so much mileage out of them that I've only opened about half of them (maybe came with 10?), and I only opened half for some color variety.

Most of the time with eyeliners, I have to wear the blackest black, for lack of …Read more

I received 3 of these liners in Mally's 14-piece mega kit waaaay back in November, and I still have tons of product left. I actually had to look back at my QVC orders to remember when I got the kit, and I was surprised as all get out that it was that long ago. It's a real shame that another reviewer's liners dried out, but mine are just as good as the day I got them …Read more

I think this would be a good choice if you use 1 eyeliner only daily and use it up fairly fast. I had one of these from a kit a year ago and without the wood or plastic around it tight like a pencil to keep the product from exposure to air, it dried up completely. I rolled it up & it was warped & dry. They are the same formulas as the pencil form and have 6 of those and have had no …Read more

Pretty good, if you ask me. It's a quite pigmented eyeliner that doesn't tug, pull, or hurt when I use it to tightline or line my upper and lower lash line. I like the fact that it's automatic and retractable. However, the cap doesn't close all the way unless I REALLY push on it and secure it. It also smudges a bit, but not too badly.

These are just okay. I honestly think all Mally's eyeliners are the same and she just repackages them with a new name every year. I have her original automatic liners, her evercolor Starlight Waterproof liners in pencil form, and her latest eye liner in pencil form that doesnt have a particular name other than color. They all wear the exact same! Last quite well on top lash line and …Read more

These are my favorite eyeliners. They glide on smooth and last all day, even in the hot summers with my oily eyelids...LOVE THEM!

I have oily lids and I actually like these quite a bit. I do have to use a primer on my lids before application but I am able to achieve a thin line along the eyelash with no tugging. The colors are quite pigmented and though they do wear off a bit during the day I find myself reaching for an oil base cleanser to completely remove it at night.

I don't normally use pencil eye liner because those I've used tend to scratch and smudge on me, so I stick to liquid eye liner. I tested the onyx on my mom who has the oiliest eye lids I have ever seen (eye liner smudges within moments!), but it held up pretty well. I also have a green and brown colors which are rather pretty.