I dont know why they bothered to make this shade again in the luxe compact. Probably just to make more money. Supposedly they are much softer. Dirt Bag is a rich dark chocolate brown. Really dark and pigmented. This glided on smoothly and lasts all day. But so did the original formula. The color is the same. Most lines have a shade similiar. Nothing special here. Skip the $19 and keep the original instead. Comes in a pink domed compact which is cute but bulky.