I am a big fan of other Eyeko mascaras as they deliver on the smudge-free front, so this one was disappointing! While it has a good intense black colour and has a soft finish, it doesn't really lengthen much. There's no volumising with this one, either. Most disappointingly, it doesn't hold a curl at all.
This would be a great mascara for someone with thick, curly lashes who needs a smudge-free darkening mascara.
I am a cruelty-free makeup user, which makes finding good products really difficult, unfortunately. I recently tried Eyeko mascara and it is, so far, the best cruelty-free mascara I've ever used. It defines and lengthens, is buildable and holds curl. It is a slightly wet formula, so you have to be careful when applying. The blue mascara is very subtle and the black, very black.
It smudges a very small amount for me, but I have oily eyes and almost every mascara smudges a LOT on me :) I'll definitely be re-purchasing.
This is a great mascara. It's a lengthening and straightening one, rather than a volumising or curling one. It gives a separate, long black lash effect. It doesn't smudge or crumble and comes off easily with a cream cleanser, but it's water resistant so face wipes aren't enough. Probably the best mascara I've ever used.
I really wanted to like this mascara but alas, it did not work for me. I got it in the duo to get the Eye Do eyeliner and I actually had higher hopes for this upon reading raves about it elsewhere. It does what it claims, lengthens -- but it does not hold my curl. I have stick straight asian lashes that don't work with many mascaras. My general problem is I curl, apply mascara and immediately lose the curl, which is the case with the Eye Do. However, it really does last and is waterproof but a little soap and water gets it off easily, unlike Fairy Drops where you need to douse it in oil. Might be a great product for someone else.