I love this stuff. After trying many natural/aluminum-free deodorants (all of which were terrible), this one thankfully changed the game for me. I've tried 3 forms of the Schmidt's: the Rose+Vanilla in a pot, the Lavender+Sage in a stick, & the Rose+Vanilla in a stick. I'd heard that the pot version worked better than the stick version so that's why I tried that one first, but after a while it felt inconvenient having to scoop some out with the little spatula, warm it between my fingers, apply under my arms, & wash my hands immediately afterwards. Plus I felt like with time it became less effective on me.
I decided to try the stick version next. Lavender+Sage smells AMAZING. I watched a review where the reviewer said, "Sorry, I don't want my armpits smelling like Lavender." Me, on the other hand... that's exactly what I want them to smell like! I used it up, then got the Rose+Vanilla stick format (equally wonderful smelling.) Another pro for me is that this stuff works. Even in 100+ degree Texas heat, I don't stink at all. This formula is natural with no harmful chemicals, and cruelty-free. I never get white marks on my shirts anymore. Also I notice many reviewers saying that this won't help with sweating at all. It helps me. I don't sweat any more or any less than when I used "regular" deodorant/antiperspirant. Also the price is right... comparable to other popular brands (I find some other natural deodorants to be overpriced.)
There's only one con I can think of: the inconvenience of the pot format, & the fact that the stick format tends to start getting a bit messy (when I close the lid some deodorant is pushed down & is visible on the outer packaging, if that makes sense). But I can easily clean it off.
I'll continue repurchasing because not only is this the best natural deodorant I've tried, it's the best deodorant I've tried period.
EDIT: In June 2018 I purchased the Ylang Ylang + Calendula stick version and HOLY SMOKES I smell like marigolds all day & am loving it.