I'd say this is a mediocre product, at best. I picked up an Eye Shimmer Pen in Starbright, which is a shimmery, frosty white. The staying power is really good, and that makes me happy because eye products just seem to slide right off me. However, just getting this onto my eyelids evenly is a major chore. Here's a hint: Don't use the actual pen. Use your finger, and use a little at a time because it dries quickly. I learned this the hard way and ended up with a huge blob of product dried to my right eyelid.