I am tempted to deduct one lippie for lack of color selection. I would love to see it in grey or blue. Other than that, this is a great product. I have relied on this for years, as my "go to" natural mascara.
The wand is pretty easy to work with, although I would also love if they would carry a version with a super thin mascara wand. Of course, that really goes for ALL mascara. With blonde lashes, I will always be a sucker for a super thin mascara wand (ie IT Tightline), so I can get my roots... With that said, this wand is pretty good at getting most of my lashes, and I love the formula.
I find that the brown is almost too natural on me, despite my status as practically an albino. Not sure why, but I prefer the black. I can only get away with black mascara if I have practically no other makeup on my eyes, but this black is natural enough that I can use it even with liner, and it won't look too harsh...
Edit: this product has been smudging on me, lately, so I removed a lippie. Did they change the formula?