Julep

My daughter gave this liner to me in Navy Smoke and when I saw the word navy, I put it aside. Later I decided to pull it out and try it and now it is my very favorite liner. It lasts longer than any liner I've used and looks more gray than navy but I love that it can pass for either. I never thought that this color would look good with dark brown eyes but it actually looks great. I also lightly brushed some on my brows and the color definitely looks gray on them. I have had to sharpen it and used a new Elf sharpener to do so. If you are very careful and don't put a lot of pressure on the pencil when sharpening, you can eliminate wasting the gel. I would definitely purchase a second pencil and plan on researching for additional colors.

Yuck! First off, I don't know if I got a bad batch or what, but this stuff smells like gasoline and turpentine. It's really unpleasant. Second, the wear time rather sucks. It creases even over primer, since you have to apply so much for it to show up. Seriously, once you blend this out, it just disappears. Also, I got the bronze shade, which looked like it would have some warmth to it in the tube. Wrong. It morphs into a dull, muddy brown shimmer that almost pulls into sickening gray/green territory. It's not crazy expensive, but it performs like dollar store makeup, so I consider this to be overpriced. Also, the packaging feels a bit flimsy. If I actually liked this nonsense product enough to use it again, I'd be worried about it breaking.

I'm surprised at the reviews. I liked this.. its definitely more for length and definition as opposed to thicken.