I bought the eye liner because it was very INEXPENSIVE just to put in my bag for emergency:)
I didn't know the pencils came with it own sharpener.
So here is the surprise findings:
I LOVE LOVE LOVE the pencil SHARPENER. It is the best pencil sharpener I have experienced!

I sharpener my other VERY expensive eyeliner with it, and it works great. And I have spent A LOT of $$$$ in the past hoping to get a good one, but none have work so well like this AZIZA brand.

The pencil eyeliner is OK, but if you are looking for pencil sharpener, then consider buying the sharpener because it came with the packageS!

Personally, i did not like this eye liner at all. First it was very dry, and hard to apply. in order to get some liner on i had to press wayy to hard. Also i did not like this product because the packaging was not so good. The sharpener was alright, i could sharpen other liners with it, but the caps were horrible. When i bent the liner upside down, the lid just fell off. No grip at all. Everyone has to try this product for themselves to see if it works well for them, but for me, i would not buy this product again.

The silkening eye pencil from Aziza is not really good but not bad either for a dollar. It goes on very light unless you press harder on it. The cap falls off easily which is annoying. It is "ok" when you get used to using it though but for a dollar it is not bad as backup or for a younger person who is experimenting.

Pretty cheap brand. The eyeliner smudged alot. The sharpener is garbage.

(I cant find the Aziza II Silklining EyePencil product on the site so I'm putting the review here, it sounds similar idk if it's the same thing though.)

Never heard of this brand before and I don't remember where it was purchased but found it at the bottom of my makeup bag so I sharpened it and gave it a try and it's horrible. It drags the skin under the eye(equals easy wrinkles) and creates a raccoon eye look after a while. It's such a bad made product...yuck. It's so cake like. Must of boughten it on a whim or something when I was desperate. Definitely not going to ever buy this stuff again...I think it was purchased at Walgreens or the dollar store. Hm who knows... Oh yeah and the color says black/brown but I would say it's light black. =[ bad purchase

Dirt cheap - bought at a dollar store -BUT - the product won't even work!

I am a sucker for 2 in 1 products, but these are just way too dry! I wonder if I would've liked them as a teenager when my skin was extremely oily? The shades I chose were called "Valley" (Like, yeahh dude, totally!) Which is a metallic dusty rose and a smoggy sky (blueish silver). The lip/cheek dusty rose is too dry for lips, so I tried it on my eyes. The color turned orangey. the eyeliner color looked silvery amethyst on my skin. Yuck.
---UPDATE---
OK, I found another one in my kit- City tones. I like this combination better!!! The lip/cheek is a metallic copper & the shadow/liner is a metallic bronze. When I smooth it down, it takes on a goldfish shimmer type effect, that's the best visual description I can give. I am obviously having a metallic phase. continued >>

Bought these in the dollar store today cause I thought the colors looked good in the package (earth) WOW ARE THEY LOUSY!!. Everything that everyone has said about them is absolutely true. Good thing I only spent 1.00.
Aziza blush and eyeshadows suck too. The colors only look good in the package.
When you apply them, there's no pigment at all!! I thought Aziza made great eye cosmetics in the past...what the heck happened?

Well, you can't always win. These are okay as eyeliners, but cheek or lipliners, they don't really do it for me, too dry or something. OH well, lost a buck..I will continue to use the "white" for under my eyes. That's all I really bought it for anyway.

Right in the trash. Buh-bye. No other pencil dragged harder on my lid. Like using a #2 pencil. Then, the caps fall off easily, too. Nice price, nice colors, lousy formula, lousy packaging.