This is my favorite makeup remover. I don't wear any waterproof products, so I can't say anything about that...but this removes anything I use. I love how it leaves my skin feeling silky smooth and super clean. The 8oz. bottle lasts me so long - I usually only buy 2 bottles a year so it doesn't end up being very expensive over time. When I buy cheap makeup remover I go through it so fast, but this Senna stuff really does the job with such a little bit of product. It doesn't irritate my sensitive skin and it has little if any scent with no added fragrance which is a bonus.
This is a decent quality eye makeup remover but no better than other more reasonably priced brands. It does not remove waterproof mascara at all. The packaging is very nice and this product does not irritate my eyes. But I think there are better makeup removers out there and would not purchase this one again.