This is a romantic looking dark brown eyeliner. The gold shimmer is subtle and nice. I wouldnt say its a black eyeliner. More of brown. I am surprised that there is only 1 person rating this nice product.
This is a beautiful shimmery dark brown (but not brown black). This is the perfect brown eyeliner on my GGG NC40 skin. Love the texture as well. I got mine from jwcosmetics.com.