Love! I've never been good with applying eyeliner in the past, it always looked too harsh no matter what the color. Now I realize its because I've been using crap drugstore eyeliners all along. These apply so smoothly, with no drag, no having to heat with a lighter to soften. I get that soft smudge blend that FINALLY looks right. It also stays in place all day. My HG!
I have 3 colors, paid $14 each, have hardly made a dent in them in 3 months.
EARTHY: A hard to describe inky blue/violet/brown. I use in place of black since black is just too harsh for me.
TAUPE: (discontinued) a little too light-works great for a natural no makeup look.
TEAK: My favorite! Dark brown with a hint of copper...makes my green eyes POP!

My absolute favorite eyeliner! If you only buy one product from Merle Norman, you have to try this eyeliner. It goes on as smooth as butter, is long-lasting, and after it sets, is smudge resistant! The creamy colors work great on the waterline, but I find the glittery ones a little bit abrasive on the waterline. Try it!

This is the best eye liner I have ever used. It glides on easily and can be smudged or left as a clean line. It does not slide or flake despite my oily skin.
I have purchased this item several times and will make a special trip to the Merle Norman store just to get another. I do not use any other MN products but, this one is worth the drive!

If you want an eye pencil that glides on, lets you smudge if desired then dries to a long lasting finish...and comes in great colors...this is the pencil for you!!! I don't like having to sharpen with a pencil sharpener, but having the little smudge sponge on the pencil end makes up for it. I'm done experimenting with other brands.

I have this in blackout, and I love it! I'm falfway through my second eye pencil of this. I am trying to decide if I want o keep purchasing this or try something new? I have no major complaints on this, I just wander if I can ever find something better? Any way..This is a great product! Goes on smooth, and it's easy to smudge to get the look you want with the little smudger tool is has but it doesn't smudge much through wear. I do notice it fades a little with time, as I am not one to look at my make up throught the day, I do it and don't touch it up at all. And by the time I get home I notice its faded. But for the most part I really like it!

This eyeliner is love in a pencil. It goes on dark and smooth to my waterline and doesn't budge an inch. If I want to smudge it, however, it smudges like a dream then stays put all day. This eyeliner is a must must must in my makeup collection, it surpasses the Urban decay eyeliner pencil in zero.

Very good stuff. Glides on very well!

Yet again, another amazing product for me; my eyes always water so I couldn't hold eyeliner - this is waterproof! It goes on so easy and is on at the end of the day - I have it in Copperized, Galaxy, Majestic and Teak! Compared to what I've paid for Lancome and Estee, this was cheap but much better!

This is my HG eyeliner! It was $14 which is a steal for an amazing eyeliner like this. I have it in Blackout and I wear it with everything. When you put it on your waterline it stay because it is waterproof (I am pretty sure that is what the lady told me) and even if its not it still stays on all day. For even longer stay time put black eyeshadow or liner over it. When I run out I will totally buy it again! (:

This is a great eye liner! It goes on super smooth, they have a great shade selection, my favorites are Earthy and Jade! This isnt the best "smudge proof" eye liner, but it does wear nicely as long as you don't touch at it. I probably would not use this for a wedding, or any "teary eyed" event... for that kind of situation I would recommend the Merle Norman Purely Mineral Eye Pencil (thats super long wearing).