Have you tried the Maybelline Lifter Liner? Creamy but very long lasting once they set.
Maybelline lifter gloss in Moon
Idk swatch photos all look like Maybelline Lifter Gloss to me. Or Fenty Gloss Balm.
About Face has one but I haven’t tried it. I buy Mac at CCO if would even try eBay. It’s often
Maybelline lifter gloss in Petal