Starlet Cosmetics--Intense Eyeliner

I've had this eyeliner forever but just recently decided to use it to see how it compares to my fave MAC liner. I received this liner when I subscribed to the Ipsy monthly subscription service...

I got this in black in an Ipsy bag. There's nothing 'intense' about this, other than it being intensely annoying to use. I've used better $1 ELF eyeliners (the shimmer ones; the regular Essential...