This is my favorite black eyeliner. I love the matte finish in puro amor. I buy this eyeliner out of habit. It lasts even through crying lol. It's worth the price and the packaging is pretty too.

My favorite eyeliner! Its super dark and it lasts all day, it is also easy to apply. It is not super thick but it is also not watery. I just love this product!

My absolute favorite liquid liner! I'm someone who demands a super dark matte black in an eyeliner, and this delivers better than any other liquid formula I've tried. It's relatively smudge resistant, and fades at the end of the day as opposed to other formulas that flake off. It typically lasts all day unless I've been rubbing my eyes more than usual. I highly recommend this product! If you're interested, you may want to purchase it soon because it looks like Sephora is starting to carry more felt pen liners (less product, more money) and may be phasing out a lot of the regular liquid formulas. I have trouble finding this in-store so I always purchase it online. I'll buy this for as long as I can!

This is a decent eyeliner. It's best for thin lines, but not as versatile as I would like it to be. It's really hard to manage a winged look with this eyeliner because of the thin bristles of the brush.


However, this liner is easy to apply and control if your desired look is a subtle look. I don't regret this purchase, and I would probably get again if I run out (or find a better one that accommodates the same purpose) considering there is no eyeliner like this one if you desire a thin line. It's very easy to use depending on what you're trying to do with it.

I absolutely loveeee this
it goes on so smoothly and its really easy to b accurate without making mistakes
its perfect if u want winged liner or just about anything really

its really smooth and doesnt dry out or start running out while your applying it

a little pricey but worth it. easily one of the best makeup products ive ever purchased

Loooove this liquid eyeliner. I have in both black and dark metallic grey. I've been using it for over a year and it is the only eyeliner I trust to stay put the entire day. I have tried a variety of gels, crayons and other liquids but this Autograph Liquid Eyeliner is the best I have ever used. It dries quickly and is not easily smudged. It is perfect for my signature cat-eye look. Love it. :-)

I have this liquid liner in the shade, "Proud Peacock" which is a blue/green color (depending on the lighting and whatever you're wearing) containing bits of shimmer (but not glitter).
This eyeliner is DIRT cheap at your local Sephora, $5 a pop, in the Sale section. I first stumbled upon this eyeliner in September, I returned a week later finding the bins to be empty; thinking that this was the last I'd ever see of this product however in December I found that they'd restocked. I'm pretty sure that they'll continue to do this for a bit longer so stock up while you can.
The formula is not too liquidy (unlike the Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid liner), and it dries pretty quickly. On the lash line this lasts for most of the day, there is still a visible line by the time I return from school; however I'm usually required to apply it again.
The brush thin, precise as well as fairly sturdy with a bit of give to make the perfect line.

I bought Black Metal Love by accident - I meant to just get the tattoo liner in black but I decided to keep it. Glad I did. It dries to a shimmery, metallic charcoal black, definitely eye catching. I kind wish it had a felt tip instead of the thin brush, I find the brush makes it more difficult to apply the liner. Also the glitter in the product does tend to move around a bit, nothing excessive, but I did notice the glitter flakes around my eyes. Easy to remove.

I have tried multiple liquid eyeliners before I tried this one. It by far has had the best pigmentation, staying power, and brush accuracy. I have the darkest black shade (Puro Amor) It literally lasts all day long! I don't know if it's just my eyelids but if I don't wipe it off with makeup remover, it WILL NOT come off. -Which is a good thing! It goes over eyeshadow very well and can make super thin or thick lines. It is definitely my holy grail item in my makeup bag.

-It is pretty pricey though /: I paid $18 oooh but SO worth it! One tube has lasted me more than a year. I apply it almost every day and the ink well looks more than half full and it is still has the same quality as the first day I bought it ! o.O
<3 !!!!
No exaggeration! continued >>

Im the one with the green eyes in the above photo. I just got this on clearance at sephora for $3 so how could i pass it up! I have it in the shade "Rhi-Venge" which is a GORGEOUS cerulean blue, almost like a rich sky blue. It really opens and brightens up my eyes, counteracts the redness that my green eyes tend to accentuate. I dont care for the brush since its sort of flimsy, but the color is pigmented. You can certainly make this work for day or night. I want to experiment more with this color!