Holy grail day-to-day eyeliner. Also works well at night, although a black is better for formal occasions. Defines the eye, but not too harsh. Glides on easily, stays all day. Easily applied to the waterline. Cons: needs to be sharpened. Worth it though.

This is a great dark brown pencil eyeliner. The color is really rich and creamy, and its perfect for everyday makeup because it isnt too bold. The staying power isnt great, but its not rally noticable unless you rubbed your eyes- it will smudge everywhere! so anyways, its a really nice product and I definitely recommend it :)

I love this eyeliner... It has a nice mix of smudgability and staying power for me. I have read the reviews about it melting off easily, but don't think I have this problem as I'm not lucky enough to have all those extra oils in my lids as some other folks. Those oils will keep you looking young!!! I typically set it with a dark brown shadow if I know I need it to stay put for a full day though, just to be safe. I will continue to purchase this...

This is a great color. Not as harsh as black, not as soft as a brown. It's a brownish black just perfect for everyday. The pencil is several inches long and will last you quite a while so it's a good value as well. With its somewhat creamy, kohl texture, it does smudge a bit so be prepared to neaten up midday. I reach for this one all the time.

I LOVE the smokey, sultry, sootyness this liner gives to my dark brown eyes...but it lacks staying power-about 30 minutes on my lower waterline and a few hours on my upper lid. It does smear, especially if you put it on your lower lid, but I don't mind because since it's a dark brown/black, it adds to the sultry and sootyness of the look instead of looking like smeared eyeliner. Despite the lack of staying power for me, it's my HG everyday liner.

I have been in LOVE with this eyeliner for YEARS... literally years. I've tried all other types, brands, gels, liquids, and this eyeliner never fails to out perform any of them. Black Coffee is a staple... it wears like no other on me... both on the water line as well as on my lids. There's never any migration and even w/every day use... these liners LAST for ages.

This eyeliner is so creamy. I love using it on my waterline. It last all day on my eyes. The liner glides on effortlessly and blends beautifully. I love this color with gold/brown eyeshadow.

I have bought so so many pencil eye liners and this is the only that does'nt smudge into my creases at the end of the day...simply the best pencil eye liner in the market...

A great product. The dark brown shade defines my eyes but doesnt look too harsh. The pencil is creamy and glides on easily. The eyeliner does smudge and transfer to my lids but adding some UDPP will stop the problem. This is my everyday go to liner:)

I love how this product just glides on without tugging and bothering my eyes, defines my eyes like a liquid liner and stays all day. I like that this is a black brown and not a true black since I have tons of eyeliners that are black. This is a great coffee shade.