I purchased this pencil on a whim as I "needed" a new liner. It costs about 6 bucks at Target for a standard size pencil and smudger at the tip. The smudger, I must say, was a bit rough albeit spongy, but it didnt really have a use. I would've preferred that extra bit to have been replaced by more pencil but it's out of my power. As for the pencil itself, it is very soft but not soft to the point that the delicate breeze from the batting of an eyelash will completely total the point... but it is soft. I found myself sharpening this pencil often, or maybe that was just me trying to get through it so I could buy another eyeliner :). In any case, the pencil was not good for drawing sharp lines and flicks, but more for soft definition of the lash line and the waterline. Staying power was normal for my eyes considering they are rather oily, although it did transfer throughout the day from lashline to my crease, but thats more due to my anatomy, ymmv. S'okay...

This eyeliner is brilliant. It's very black but not overpowered black-very wearable still. I can use this of a day without it being too dramatic. I love it.

I have this is black and brown. I bought each ne with a voucher so they cost me £2.50 each. I bought the brown as I fell in love with black. I use the brown as an eybrow pencil and it is perfect and lasts ll day.
I have real trouble applying eyeliner but find these glide on and are really soft on the skin with no dragging.
The colour is sublte and mistakes can be easily rectified with the smudger at the other end of the pencil,if you want a really striking black then a liquid product may be best as I find these colours not as dark.
Great staying power and easily removeable.

This product works great. I bought it in Black and it certainly is that! It has a strong colour, this one is actually black not some greyish non-black colour you get when you buy a low quality eye pencil. It has a hardish feel to it not to squishy and it stays sharp for quite long. I also thought it was worth the money.

I love, love, love this eyeliner!! I use it every single day for going out and it stays on for ages!! It's great for smudging too, if you want to do a smokey eye effect! I have recommended this product to so many people and I will probably keep using it for as long as I possibly can!

I just needed a classic black eye pencil when I saw this at Target. I loved the blending tool on the opposite end. I used this eyeliner in a swimming class for 4 months and it never faded, flaked or let me down. Overall, this is a great backup eyeliner if my gel runs out. It glides on nice and smooth.

Bought this with no7 voucher.

Needs a bit of practice before you realise what a good product it is. The pencil is soft and creamy and glides on nicely. I prefer the chunkyness of the pencil as you can create a smoky effect with the smudger bit.

Sometimes it does leave a mark on my eyelid which is terrible, i find myself wiping it off during the day. Perhaps eye primer may help.

Nevertheless, its a good product, I will repurchase again for sure. Love the softness of the application.

The glittery version of this pencil is uber soft and creamy, so will purchase this too!

I bought this eyeliner in Blue Grey. I got this because I was looking for a grey eyeliner and didn't really find any with the other brands. I figure I would try this since it's $7, not too bad considering other brand name eyeliners costing around $18. The color is not that intense or too pigmented, but it's ok because I'm not looking for an intense color anyways. I have swipe it over 2-3 times for the colors to show up nicely, it's a nice greyish blue/indigo color. It defines my eyes and the color is not too harsh for underneath my eyes. It doesn't transfer to my upper lids or smudges too much. For the price, it's not too bad.

I love love love these eyeliners - stays on all day with little smudging, strong colour, looks good. Waaay too expensive for me to buy without the voucher though.

I have been using this eyeliner for about a year now and its amazing. I first brought it when I received my £5 boots vouncher so got it for £2.50, which is great. Mine doesnt smudge at all. I always wear heavy eyeliner even in the day, and have tried many eyeliners, but I dont bother anymore as I have found the perfect one for me. I always buy backups, and whenever I get that voucher, I dont bother looking for anything new at the No7 counter, as I know I'll need this :)