Pencil Eye Liner

This is called Pencil Eye Liner Waterproof. I have the shade 02 which is the gorgeous warm almost wine brown color. I give it 2 points just becuase of the unusual color. I got this in a swap stil...

I think this would be my favourite pencil liner. I've tried the MUFE Aqua eyes as well as Integrate's pencil liners and both smudge pretty badly for me. My friend had sent me her P&J pencil liner...

Bought the one in No 1. It's a new release, different from the dual pencil. This one goes on smooth, colour intensity is pretty good, BUT it smudges like crazy even with a primer. In an hour...