Amazing product. I spent approx £20 on the chanel version of the waterproof eyeliner and at £4 this one is just as good if not better! Stays on the waterline all day with no irritation. I buy two at a time so I don't run out!
LOVE this eyeliner... stays on all day and doesn't run! I have sensitive eyes; sometimes I wear contacts and this doesn't bother my eyes at all! I will always repurchase when I run out!
Oh. My. God. Why has no one told me about this amazing waterproof eyeliner before!?
How on earth have I missed this gem of a product, when the make up aisles in Superdrug are like my second home?
I use this on my waterline and hands down it's the one product that actually stays nearly all day. Most others fade within half an hour and end up all over my undereye area making me look like I have bags under my eyes. I love that it's one of those twisty pencils that don't require you to carry a sharpener around with you.
This is absolutely HG status.
I must be on number 5 of these now - if not more.
If I don't have time to use any other makeup (or cannot be bothered) this is the thing that makes me feel human again. It never lets me down and lives forever in my handbag.
Only critique is that on a few of them the smudging/sharpener end has fallen off and gotten lost. my current one hasn't though. If I run out I get myself to Boots asap.
Awful! I like the packaging and the way it twist sharpens, plus the extra little sharpener for extra definition. I despise the eyeliner itself. I felt like a little kid with a crayon scribbling on my eyes in frustration when one layer after another barely showed up. Pressing harder and harder till I ended up just making a big angry mess all over my face. Never fear though the smudger does not smudge, it basically removes the eyeliner. Perfect for my purposes, not so perfect for those intending to smudge the liner. Although this does seem to be fairly waterproof, that doesn't mean you shouldn't check your eyeliner fairly often as it is not at all smudge proof.
Grabbed this Eyeliner for very little at the local shoppers drug mart because it had the sponge tip smudger and I was really curious to try it. The actual eyeliner itself is quite good and I usually use it every day or every other day, however the sponge applicator is not very good. I wouldn't suggest using it because it kind of just takes all the color of your actual liner - if you're looking for a cheap eyeliner smudger, this isn't for you. As for the eyeliner I would definitely give it 5/5 but for the sponge applicator its a no-go for me. A cool kind of hidden feature is the sharpener that is actually with the sponge when you pull it out, it helps to get super sharp lines if you're going for a non-liquid cat eye.
This is my new favorite eyeliner! Up until I got this I used Rimmel's Scandaleyes Kohl Kajal waterproof liner pencils and they were so messy when you sharpened them and although I loved the bold color and that they glided on, it was hard to sharpen them right, and they ran out too quickly for the price. This is basically the same liner but a lot less messy. The pigment is still really strong and bold especially the more you build up the color. It lasts for a long time, especially on the lashline. I carry it with me when I leave the house because although it stays on the waterline more than any other eyeliner I've used, it still needs reapplied eventually. It doesn't smudge, it doesn't need sharpened, and it lasts for a long time. It's 6 dollars at K-mart but at Target it's only $4.44. It glides right on without making a mess and I absolutely adore this.
Best drugstore eyeliner that I tried (up until now that is, April 2013) because it is cheap and very well made. The packaging doesn't look cheap at all. It's like the drugstore version of chanel waterproof eyeliner. Of course chanel's eyeliner stays better and longer compared to this one but it's a lot more expensive too. It does smudge a bit for me, but its nothing major and and this price, I can't complaint. Love it!
This is a nice black eyeliner although I still experience smudging with this, despite its waterproof claims. It defiantely smudges less than most eyeliners *cough cough Maybelline* and stays on my waterline for considerably longer than other brands.
I wouldn't buy this again just because I don't like worrying about whether my eyeliner is smudged or not
Brilliant. Amazing that you don't have to sharpen it. Stays on all day. Great for top lid too because it draws easily. Best eye liner yet.