Argan Lip Sting Plumping Butter

I do keep reaching for this product. It does moisturize very well and does add kind of a plumpness to my lips. I use it with a super bright lip pencil by Bobbi Brown (Raspberry) and it looks...

At the time of purchase (12/17), this new product from Josie Maran came in 3 shades. I ordered this buttery lip stick in what looked like the darkest shade, "Grapefruit." When it arrived, I was...