Mary Kay Ultimate Mascara

I think this is as close as I am going to get to a HG mascara. This is reasonably priced (compared to department store and Sephora prices) and it wears BEAUTIFULLY. Application tip: BLOT the brush before putting this on- especially when brand new. The brush is fluffy, but not bulky. The formula is not wet, but not overly thick. I get really good volume and definition with only one or two coats and it layers very well. The black color is rich and true. I am especially pleased this doesn't give me raccoon eyes (even with oily skin) but it removes easily enough with a gentle cream cleanser! Mary Kay has a real winner with the Ultimate and I hope they never discontinue it!

For some reason the brush doesn't work for me- like i can't get the mascara off the tightly-packed bristles and on to my eyelashes? So bizzare! I could go to the trouble of cleaning a wand I do like and using that, but that sounds very messy. I'll probably go back to a Loreal or maybelline mascara like always- there are so many varieties and the cost is much less

I order a lot of products from Mary Kay and this mascara is one of them. I paid for $15 before tax. It a very great mascara. It gives volume and length to my lashes. Love it.

Wet yet clumpy...spidery crooked lashes...one coat not enough - two coats and it looks like you have exactly three lash clumps stuck to your eye...sounds fun, doesn't it? I tried to like this mascara, each day thinking I hadn't found the knack of applying it but...I give up.

The first tube was amazing. It's not really natural though, kind of just straight not flared out. But the volume is amazing and it separates. But the second tube was terrible!!! Super sticky and NO VOLUME!!! And sticky and spiky, wire looking lashes. I check the batch code and it exist... Maybe it is a fake??

This is one of the best mascaras I have tried, and it is cheaper than the "high brands" that I usually buy. It separates the lashes, and give you a lot of volume.

This is wonderful mascara, really lengthens and thickens and has a really rich black color. I thought I'd found my HG mascara, but... it dries up sooo fast and for $16 I expected more, too pricey to replace every couple of weeks.

From the first application of this mascara -- I knew I would love it. It is very black, gives nice volume and length, doesn't flake (which is huge for me), and the wand is nice for spreading my lashes out. The only con is that it can be clumpy. But I just take my favorite Clump Crusher mascara and apply that after this mascara and that takes away any clumps. But this mascara kind of makes me look like I'm wearing false lashes. It's a keeper.

Okay, I really didn't like this mascara. It didn't curl my straight eyelashes, and it was clumpy and wet, and it smudged a lot. For people who have straight asian eyelashes like mine, I recommend Rimmel's Scandaleyes Retro-Glam. Love that mascara!

This mascara is great for my long blonde lashes. The color is rich and it volumizes without too much clumping. I ran out and went back to my old favorite--loreal voluminous--and regretted it. Must buy this again asap.