I didn’t adore the color, at first, before trying it; but I have to admit that this mascara is actually flattering. I’d prefer a slightly more navy/grey color, but I’m happy they carry a natural looking blue mascara, especially in this formula, which I love! I have fine, blonde, feathery lashes—lots of them. I sometimes want a more natural look, and I get it w/ this mascara, ironically, even though royal blue lashes aren’t normally “natural” looking! The color is not electric blue, so it actually doesn’t read “blue” once on, at least on me. It looks more natural than black, too. I was using it only on the bottom lashes, since I prefer the color of my Chanel/YSL (but those wands are too big for bottom lashes), but it’s so easy to apply (formula/brush) that I got lazy and began using it on bottom and top. I’m actually really pleased w the result! Just as Great Lash is a classic formula, this is a really classic color. It would look STUNNING on brown eyes, since it’s almost a warm blue. Green and hazel would look great w/ it, too. I’ve got blue eyes, but this isn’t anything like the 80’s monochrome blue on blue. It’s much more flattering, somehow. Thumbs up! At this price point, you can’t go wrong. Give it a try!
Edit/Update: I removed two lippies for slight smudging. If I don’t powder under my eyes and/or stay away from outdoor activity, this may smudge. I wore it on a hike in the mountains and had sunscreen on, which was apparently too much for it to handle, and it ended up giving me blue raccoon eyes. I think I’ll stick with Chanel!