My favorite highlighter, by a landslide, has been the Living Luminizer since I bought a pot two years ago (yes, it's really lasted me that long, applied 5 days a week). Until I tried Rosé. The slight pink sheen just really does it for me. Without access to actual samples, I tried to do some research on this shade and found very little resources compared to the others in the line. I was mainly concerned about the texture differing from the original, but I'm happy to say that it's retained the same intense, high-gloss sheen and fairly low viscosity. For comparison, the texture of the Magic Luminzer is drier and has more grip than the original, while the Rosé is at least equal to, if not slightly oilier than, the original.
While it appears nude-toned in the pan with a pink highlight that is neither cool nor warm, it appears completely sheer on my skin with a tiny bit of pink where the light hits. Some people may be disappointed that there isn't greater color payoff with the pink pigment, but for me, this strikes just the right balance where it's visible but not in danger of clashing with the rest of my makeup. I'm very pale though, so it could read differently.
There is no smell and, like I mentioned, it is extremely high-gloss due to the coconut and castor oils-- it looks quite wet on the skin and does not dry down, though it feels weightless. It applies well over my cream blush (I use my fingers to tap it on) and doesn't appear to migrate. I don't recommend using it on places like the bridge of your nose or on the inner corners of your eyes if you wear foundation, though, because the high oil content tends to break it down... at least in a much more visible way. Lasted well through an 8-hour day. No complaints about the packaging: the frosted glass feels good and solid and the cap stays put. Going off of the Living Luminizer lasting me almost two whole years with daily use, I expect this to be pretty much the same.
This is definitely my new favorite and I highly recommend giving this a try if you love any of the other RMS highlighters or generally enjoy glossy shine over shimmer or glitter.