I'm surprised I like this product. I really disliked Jergens Natural Glow moisturizer (the kind that was NOT designed for use in the shower) because of the smell. That stuff just STANK. This product has a noticeable scent, too. It's a strong scent, but ti's not the same scent as was in the previous product, and it dissipates more quickly than the one that was in the other product. So, I can deal with this scent, I'm thinking. Time will tell. On to the issue of the self tanning performance-it's pretty darned good! It's not orangey. It's not too dark, but it's not so light that you have to keep reapplying for days on end to get anywhere near some color. A couple of days application will give me what I'd call a nice base tan. It's also just plain old darned convenient! You wipe this on wet skin fresh after showering, then towel off. You do have to take a bit of care to rub the lotion in on your legs evenly, but it's really not any more time consuming than the usual lotion application. The convenience of this product is pretty unbeatable. It doesn't stain your towels or your clothing. The color is quick developing and natural looking. I am reviewing the light to medium tone, so I imagine you could get even darker results if that's your thing with the medium to deep. I haven't tried that color, because I'm light skinned enough I don't think it'd look natural on me. I think Jergens Natural Glow Wet Skin is worth a try as long as you aren't fragrance sensitive.