I only bought this beucause Tati Westbrook on Youtube mentioned it along with Flower Beauty as being good drug store setting sprays. It was a comment in passing. The only other setting spray I"ve used is the Maybelline one which does not stand out in a partically positive or negative way. The one I have says "natural finish"
PROS: I have normal to dry skin and I do feel this adds some luminosity. I am trying for a no makeup look, not really adding products for dimension but just having a healthy sheen/glow. It is the winter right now and usually my skin isn't that much drier, but it is at the moment so I use this to cheat a bit to make my skin look more hydrated. I am using this under The Ordinary's NMF + HA moisturizer, which is a dry-finish/smooth drydown type moisturizer and either Covergirl Outlast Stay Luminous, Loreal True Match Lumi, or MUFE ULtra HD foundation, with minimal amount of powder or no powder at all. This is probably overkill however for most people. It can be striaght up LUMINOUS and DEWY looking, like a clear sheen or the need to powder but I'm liking it at the moment. With that I also do feel like it does help my makeup to last and it's cheap.
CONS: The sprayer on this... It is a long spray that practically "blasts" you with ridiculously large drops. No exxagerattion at all! There is nothing mist-like or delicate about it. I would need to hold my arm quite far back to tone it down and I'm just not doing that because it feels wrong and is too far back. WHY do the drops feel gigantic when they hit my skin though!? The Maybelline one wasn't like that. And the width of the spray isn't even that wide, so good luck trying to precisely control it to hit the eye area for example. And I always look WET after I use this, like a mild drenching. I seriously believe they only chose this sprayer for price and fact that the consumer won't be wasting product anytime soon.
While I like that it also does give me some glow, I feel that it doesn't really help powder to meld to the skin or soften a powdery look. If I were to powder too much, this would give me a harsh look or shine over a too matte base, instead of softening the matte look itself, you know what I mean?
I also HATE the fact that it's such a small bottle. This is terrible for the environment because you need to buy twice as much as other setting sprays!
OVERALL: I might actually buy this again because so it does seem to work. I don't mind too much the fact that is sprays the hell out of my face, but I will definitely look at Flower's setting spray as my next purchase. I may try the matte one come summer or read reviews first.