Ultra-Smooth Waterproof Eye Defining Pencil in Mulholland

Not overpriced and it does stay put much better than my UD pencil. The only reason I didn't give it a 5 is that the shade, Mulholland, looked nice swatched on the inside of my wrist but on application didn't do much for my blue eyes. There's a bit of red in it, I don't see it as a neutral taupe, most of a medium chestnut. I need something darker to make my eye pop. But …Read more

This is a fast-setting, long-wearing matte taupe pencil that is extremely versatile! I saw this pencil in action watching Tati's review of Fiona Stiles products, and was intrigued by Mulholland, wondering if it was good at being both a lipliner and an eyeliner, and it is!

For lips, this color is ideal for doing a stealthy line (has to be tapped in and made a little softer …Read more