Superhero Mascara

Nope, not for me. I got a mini-size with a Sephora order and was excited to try it, but after a week of use, I tossed it. It clumps right up on my lashes, which I HATE -- it held the curl a little bit but I can't deal with clumps. It also left little tiny bits of mascara on my lashes and didn't comb through nicely, another pet peeve. My lashes looked spidery and stiff after …Read more

This mascara is really a mixed bag for me. I've had the full size and the sample size, both of which I got in subscription boxes. It's a wetter formula, and it doesn't dry quickly. It leaves little tiny clumpy balls on my lashes. It does give me quite a bit of volume and length, I will definitely give it that. But the really bad part for me is that it smudges-I look like a …Read more

I've used this mascara almost exclusively for the past year and liked it so much I bought it for my daughters. In an attempt to save a little $ I stocked up with a 2 for $30 deal through HSN. For some reason the tubes I bought from them have been flakey. My one daughter noticed it as well and by the end of the day we are rubbing mascara flakes out of our eyes. Very disappointing since I had …Read more

I have been using a sample of this mascara and I am blown away by it. It instantly gives volume & length to my lashes and looks as if I am wearing false eyelashes. It does not flake or smudge on me throughout the day like some other mascaras I have used. My only minor complaint would be that I have to use an eyelash comb (sometimes) to unclump a few lashes here and there; but other than that …Read more

One of the worst mascaras I’ve ever used. The brush doesn’t have enough bristles to comb through my lashes. The formula dries very quickly and flakes. You would think a fast drying formula would have the advantage of not smearing. But, somehow it achieves that undesirable effect on my bottom lash. The formula in the bottle dries very fast as well and becomes clumpy. Thankfully, this was a …Read more

I liked this enough to use up a trial size but it didn't wow me. I agree with another reviewer that the volume/curl isn't there, it doesn't build the way I like. However it lengthens and looks nice enough, it's reliable as an everyday mascara and I would use a sample again. I just wouldn't buy it.

Garbage mascara. I'm glad I only spent $12 on the trial size at Ulta and I will be taking it back. I had high hopes for this one but there are better drug store mascaras out there than this.

Just awful. Great brush, but the formula is literally the worst I’ve ever used. It’s so dry and crumbly. My lashes are naturally long and full. This left them looking sparse and full of little clumps...like the squashed carcasses of a long, spindly legged spiders.

This is my all time favorite mascara (and I’ve tried almost everything from drugstore to high end). I’ve repurchased IT superhero 4 times. I was dubious at first because I’m not a fan of IT products in general. For whatever reason this mascara gives me fake looking lashes with just a few swipes. The length it gives me is insane. I get asked regularly if I’m wearing fake eyelashes. No other …Read more

The wand overloads with product like crazy. I have to wipe so much gunk off before applying and even still sometimes my lashes are overloaded with product. Like it's bad to the point I'll see black clumps in my vision, just way way too much product. On top of that this is a wet formula that takes a long time to dry, so while it's drying if im not careful my lashes that I …Read more