A little about my skin before I get onto the review: Very fair and cool toned (pink undertone) skin.
I bought Dulce De Leche because it looked cool toned in the pan but unfortunately the coolness of the contour powder reads orange on my skin even when swatched on my inner arm that is a white "fish belly" color (super fair, even more so than my face) it still pulled orange. I hate when this happens when it comes to a seemingly cool toned product.
Now, the quality of the product is good, it blends well, is super pigmented, both sides have a very smooth formula so 5 lippies as far as the quality of the powders go.
I find most contour products made seem to cater to light skin folks all the way to the medium skin end of the skin tone spectrum, leaving us very fair and super deep folks out of the thought process when it comes to making decent contour products for us which is unfortunate.
This WnW Contouring Palette will be heading to Project Beauty Share so it's not a total loss, just not for me as far as contour goes.
I'm guessing because of how pale I am I benefit from a grey contour powder which has been my feeling all along. I have LA Girl Just Because heading my way so hopefully that will better suit my very fair, cool toned skin.
Contour products I've tried in case anyone is interested from a very fair person's experience trying to find decent contour products:
Nyx Taupe, this pulls extremely rosy (pink) on me but swatched on my inner arm it has a purple hue to it, doesn't look the best like it does on light skin tones versus my super fair skin.
Victorious from Addictive Cosmetics (a Chanel Notorious dupe is their claim), this ended up going bad within 2 weeks of purchase, it started smelling like crayons which really peeved me off. This is a little less rosy than Nyx's Taupe but can still pull a tiny smidge rosy on me unfortunately but overall it wasn't too bad of a color on me. I did end up throwing this away because it went bad.
Nyx Wonder Stick in Light, too rosy but does have a taupe (slightly purple) tone to it. Once blended out, it blends into nothing so I advise not even entertaining the thought of trying this. Again, undertone is rosy or what makeup companies like to call "taupe." Lazarus from KvD Shade & Light Eye pulls a yellowy bronze color on me so it's not a true contour color on me like it would have you believe it would be in the pan.
Shiro Cosmetics Do Your Research. This is a true gray color, hallelujah! This is amazing as a contour for the super fair, sample size is very generous imo if anyone is interested in trying a sample size before you buy. A true cool toned grey, no odd "taupe" color (*cough* I mean rosy or purple) to be had here, this is is a straight up natural shadow in a jar for the super fair. Doesn't pull any odd, off putting colors on me like purple, orange or rosy. All I get is a true natural looking shadow on my face from this. This powder is super pigmented, a little goes a long way and it blends so easily on the skin. For now I will say this is my HG contour powder but I'm always on the hunt for new grey contour products for my super fair skin. I can't wait to get LA Girls Just Because in the mail.