I'm murderous on eyeliner and most fall fall short. This one, however, delivered, in spades. I had ordered it from a special offer on Ipsy and received it just before going on my first trip to Europe from the States. So I went to Dublin, Ireland, and I soon found myself enjoying pub culture maybe slightly too much (found that "craic" of which the Irish speak so highly) -- in my defense, Guinness really does taste better in Ireland. Anyway, after a night spent drinking potentially toxic amounts of stout, yell-talking (because I go deaf when inebriated, apparently), dancing (badly) to live Irish folk music and subsequently then vomiting in the street, lying on the sidewalk, riding in a cool yellow Irish ambulance (oh, yes, I did) and sleeping it off in an Irish ER (where the cute Irish doc giggled at me when I finally woke up and was able to tell him who I was), THEN coming home (stopping for more barfing twice along the way) in my bra and denim jacket because I'd ruined my shirt -- THE EYELINER HADNT BUDGED OR SMUDGED OR ANYTHING. And that, my makeup maven friends, is the mark of a good product. I shall buy lots more of this magic stuff.