Longlasting Eye Pencil Waterproof

I have Pearly Bird 100 love this ! build-able. can be used as both eyeshadow and inner eye corner highlight [inner corner is my biggest use of it ] , great if you are in a rush because you just apply and then voila! you're done ! natural finish unless you apply much, blends with difficulty though so that needs to improve, blends best with a finger if you want to use it as eyeshadow or face highlighter. works beautifully over a white shadow. update: product breaks a bit if you put pressure on it with a finger so be careful. I would buy again , affordable. nice shimmery [a bit foiled ] shade. economic packaging, comes with sharpener [which I didn't need] lasts a long time despite multiple use. bit hard to remover, best removed with cotton bud that has makeup remover on , dab some times and it goes away. just make sure to really get in there. but it does remove well, I use Byphasse milk cleanser.works wonders.

Just great! Stays all day, easy to aply, lasts long and can be removed easily. It does not irritate my eyes. Much better than lot of more expensive eye pencils. I will buy it again.

I have this in Brown & I love it. It basically really *is* waterproof for the most part. There are other waterproof eyeliner pencils out there that are maybe better (mostly liquids but pencils that come to mind are Smashbox Always Sharp but it's $20. eek!). Easily removed w the method I use to remove my makeup (Magic Eraser), not much scrubbing. This pencil is ~$5 & may look plain no frills but it does what its job is to do which is to sit on my upper eyelid & stay there for 8+ hours til I want to remove it. It's unusual to find a pencil that actually IS waterproof & I've got very rheumy eyes/oily lids which can challenge the best of the best. Catrice is a brand I've never seen well I found it off Ulta dot com if ur looking, but I'm very impressed. Basic brown color, idk what other colors are available besides brown & of course black coz I usually only am interested in those 2. This rivals my fave DS priced waterproof pencil which is made by Essence. I'm still searching for my HG waterproof pencil (but Smashbox really IS hard to beat!).

This is one of the best waterproof liners ive ever come ive got it in black and it would last all night without me having to retouch it ( even in the waterline!!!) Amazing product. And dirt cheap! It can be a tad hard to remove, i use an oil based makeup remover.

I've never heard of this brand before until I was shopping in Phuket - I found that this crayon eye liner barely smudges for me. I've used a lot of crayons/gel/pencils and they all seem to smudge A LOT. Though, not all eyeliners are perfect, this does smudge a little but not to the point where I look like a drug addict. As this is a waterproof eyeliner, it's annoying to remove and would require lots of make up removers.