Caresse Wet Shine- Endless Red

So when the YSL glossy stains came out, I obsessed for a while and almost bought one despite the cost, but I didn't find a shade I really wanted. So when these dupes came out I bought Endless Red...

I have two of these. I have Endless Red and Stubborn Plum. I was hoping for an actual stain and gloss but sadly these are more of a liquid lipstick. . I am a NW20 and that's summer. Winter I...