This is probably one of my most disappointing products I've bought from ELF, mostly because it just doesn't work very well. If they would have packaged these like the new Aqua lip stains (like a gel) it would have been much better. I have the color Nude Nectar, and like others have mentioned, this isn't nude. It pulls very red on my lips. Red brown. I'd like to have it pull subtle, but because the tip doesn't work very well (mine feels like it's dried out, but it's not, I think that's just the "marker" applicator) I'm not able to really apply it lightly, because it just marks my lips up like a marker (lines).
I do find that if I apply it leaning on one of the tip's sides, more color applies, and then I just press my lips together to spread the color to my top lip - but this is not something I'd repurchase. I like the color, and when I test the product on my arm, the color comes out 100% nude and light, but on my lips, it's just not the same. It's a cute idea, though. Will try to use up, but won't repurchase. The fine tip makes a good lip liner though.
Doesn't last at all on my lips. I can lick my lips - and the color is almost gone, no matter how much I put on. Which, I don't know about you, but I don't like the idea of eating my lip color constantly.