NYX Professional Makeup Wonder Pencil

Perfect for small cover jobs. I bought medium and it blends perfectly. Doesn't budge, can be used under or over foundation.

I am on my 5th one, and wish I had found it sooner!!! I line around my lips - even if I am not wearing lipstick so it looks more polished. This can be used directly under your brow as well.

An inexpensive multipurpose tool that really adds a nice final touch to my makeup looks. I use this only for the inner corner and my lower waterline and I like how it's still brightening (I have the lightest shade) but it isn't stark white and unnatural looking. Knocking one lippie off because it says it can be used to lightly conceal acne and be a reverse lip liner, but because this doesn't blend very well I found it to be bad for both. It left little white spots over my face I couldn't buff out, and I couldn't blend it out when I reverse lined my lips so I had a super awkward "milk mustache". Because this was only like $5 I'm happy using it just on my eyes though

I use this to brighten the inner corners of my eyes. It's pretty amazing, cheap and lasts forever. I'm pretty sure I've got mine in 2012, and it is still going. It's one of those products that you tend to forget about, but when you don't have it you will severely miss it. I highly recommend this in the light shade for brightening the eyes. Naturally if you're looking to use this as a concealer then choose the shade that works with your skintone best.

Excellent for lower waterline brightening, brow definition, around the tear ducts and reverse lip lining. My skin tone is a neutral med-tan and the light shade works perfectly. This would also conceal small areas like pimples as well since the pencil is on the soft side and easy to blend but Id need to go for a deeper shade for that. Great inexpensive little work horse. I use it every day and really love it for days when I'm wearing little makeup and just need a little something for tired looking eyes.

I mainly use this on the lower inner rim of my eyes to brighten them. The color is nice and opaque, and I find it to be fairly long lasting. I also have used this as a base for eye shadow since it is just a tiny bit darker than my eyelid color. It is a little dark for me to use it as a reverse lip liner, but it doesn't feel bad on the lips themselves. This is a makeup product that seems like it doesn't really do much, but it is handy to have in your collection since it does its job very well.

I have NYX wonder pencil in medium. It's a bit softer and needed much more sharpening than WnW calling your buff. The medium tone is very similar to WnW; medium is a tiny bit pinker, WnW is a tiny bit more yellow. Both are fine for waterline; NYX a bit easier to glide on, but WnW doesnt smudge as much. For the price, i get multiples and line away as per mood. I do prefer a firmer pencil for nude reverse lining my upper lip. Somehow the softer one isnt as crisp. But then it needs more blending. Also useful for around the brow definition. The NYX is short enough to fit into a cosmetic case, whereas the WnW is super long. (I have a variety of WnW eye pencils and Calling Your Buff and the white one are noticeably softer -- I think WnW reformulated).
Incidentally I prefer both this product and the WnW to NYX milk which i could not make work. I also prefer this to RImmel and Milani eye pencils which tend to smudge more on me. I am not sure about this in comparison to Sephora nano. Nano is firmer, requires less sharpening and doesnt crumble as fast. But, on me, Nano also smudges. WnW eye shadow primer helps prevent smudging, but doesn't help with under lash lining. I am NC30-35, asian olive skin.

Love. This. Product!!!! I use it for many things: to line under my eyes so my eyeliner doesn't melt into my under eye area from my waterline, as a reverse lip liner for bold lips, a highlight on the inner corner of my eye, an under brow liner....I mean the applications are endless! I will absolutely buy this again. It has found a place as a must have in my makeup kit.

Purchased this primarily for the waterline. Sadly it made my eyes runny and watery, so sensitive/allergic to it. Works ok as reverse line on lips and on brow bone. In summary I'm down the middle, I'd avoid if you have sensitive eyes.

I use this on my lower waterline to make my eyes like bigger and more awake. It is a great colour for me - pretty natural looking, the best nude waterline colour that I have found so far and I have a tried a few. My only complaint, which is the same for all eyeliner pencils that I have put on my lower waterline, is that it often gets into my lash line and clumps-up breaking the natural look that I am trying to achieve. I have tried running a spooley and mascara through the lashes to fix the issue, but no success there.