These are awesome. I love MAC cremesheen glosses and these are like of the drugstore version for me. The glosses are not super sticky (which is why I do not like MAC lip glasses, and instead only wear cremesheen glosses). The packaging is nice because the tube is the color of the gloss and the doe foot is great. NYX has a problem with giving colors name that do not match the product (such as "Cherry Cheesecake" being orange, "Peaches and Cream" being a warm pink, etc) so buyer beware. They have a vanilla scent, which I also find nice. I have a handful of them (Praline, Gingersnap, Madeleine, Cherry Cheesecake). I have had more over the years, but have gotten rid of them because the color didn't suit me; no issues with formula or the packaging. I am an NC30/35 and Praline and Madeleine are great "my lips but better" colors. If you are darker than me, Gingersnap is for you. To me, glosses like this look beautiful on the lips because you can still see a bit of the natural lip, while still wearing a pigmented gloss. I also like the way these glosses (and MAC cremesheens) look layered over lipstick. Maybe it is just my imagination, but because the gloss base is not clear (at one of the spectrum) and yet not super opaque (on the other), it gives different look to the lips that I find quite beautiful.