I really love the Marvelous Moxie glosses and the Buxom ones, so I'm not giving this 3 stars because the product is bad. These are great for plumping, they feel nice, they aren't sticky and they are on sale enough that they are a great value. I've had one of my favorite heavy use shades almost 2 years.
But I've got to be honest, this darker shade is not my favorite. I think the colors that work best in this formula are lighter shades, or glitter ones, or metallic bronzey shades. One thing I've consistently found is the deeper or red shades bleed on me or slip a bit more. They still look nice but they require a bit of cleaning up from time to time. I still like it, but I will just buy the lighter shades from now on.