WRITE A REVIEW
82% would repurchase
Package Quality: 4.3
Creme Eye Liner Pencil
Benefit Cosmetics BADgal Waterproof Eye Pencil
Filter by skin/hair/eye
Filter by age
Start your review
on 12/13/2016 6:47:00 PM
More reviews by chusuyuki
Skin: Very Oily, Other, Not Sure
Hair: Red, Other, Other
Tried this on the back of my hand and found it to be difficult to remove without makeup remover. Hence I bought it. I applied this in the morning at 7am and it smudges onto my undereye area at about 9.30am. The color has also started to become lesser and lesser due to my oily eyelids. Comparing this to shu Uemura, I would prefer the latter for it's wonderful staying power, though shu's drawing pencil tip is very soft.
on 12/4/2016 5:29:00 AM
More reviews by generalodin
Skin: Other, Other, Not Sure
Hair: Other, Other, Other
Pros - Very creamy and glides without tugging on your lids- Colors are pigmented and available in a reasonable selection Cons - Pricey if compared to other eyeliners which performed similarly in the market- It SMUDGES like big time if you have oily lids as I do Conclusion : Won't be repurchasing. Rather try out other alternatives.
1 of 1 people found this helpful.
on 5/26/2016 10:56:00 AM
More reviews by tvxqgirl
Skin: Acne-prone, Fair-Medium, Warm
Hair: Black, Kinky, Medium
I have this in shade #1, Beige Shine, for application under the eyes. At the drugstore, I was instantly impressed with the creamy application and colour payoff when I swatched it on my hand. But the price gave me pause. Eventually, I went home with it and didn't regret it. I apply this gel liner under my eyes and at the inner corners. The liner lasts, way better than my Canmake liner and there is even a pencil sharpener at the opposite end. I'm now contemplating buying a darker shade for lining the eyes even though I generally prefer liquid eyeliners.
on 12/6/2015 10:04:00 PM
More reviews by asherzoby
Skin: Combination, Medium, Not Sure
Hair: Black, Straight, Fine
This could be my HG pencil eyeliner! I am going to do the review for the navy chic one first. Product wise - this goes on really smoothly that even i was amazed. When i used without my etude eye primer, it managed to sit to on my oily lids for about 4 hours without budging - no smudge, no flaking. It was also easily removed with a gentle swipe with my maybelline eye lip remover. The drawback was that it probably won't do for tight lining. The gel pencil tip is just not fine enough so you got to work with a thicker line. with my etude eye primer though, it seems to be more smudgy. not sure if it was because i did not wait for it to dry completely with the primer before adding on my eye shadow? Hence, i have to minus away one lipstick for this. With the primer, it doesn't sit as well, it is now mixing with my etude house eye shadow to give a smudgey smokey effect. hmm. colour wise - i don't think i am suitable for blue. it is a nice bright navy blue with fine glitters. the glitters don't disturb my eyes thankfully. however, it does look a bit 80s on me. I had bought it because it was the most raved about colour but i guess for office wear, you probably shouldn't do the blue unless you can carry it off. update for blue - i am not sure if it is just this particular pencil but i just can't get it sharpen right. it will break off so easily that i think i wasted almost 1/4 to half of the product! colour wise - this is the review for golden khaki. gorgeous colour but my MAC desire and devices still wins hands down for the colour. i was half hoping golden khaki would be suitable replacement but the golden khaki is rather flat and not as metallic. it also appears darker and not as bronzy/golden as i had hoped. I havent' yet sharpen the pencil but the formula seems hardier and less creamy (but still very soft and glidable) as compared to the blue. still feeling hopeful! EDITS - its easier to sharpen! yay! Colour wise - this is the review for bloody devil. Its a beautiful colour!!! its not boring black but its not too bold or loud for the office. I think it goes well with the yellow tone chinese skin. It tends to seep into my creases after 4 hours but i haven't yet tried it with the etude eye primer. I love the glitter bits that this colour has. It goes on very creamy soft but i am half afraid that it will be very difficult to sharpen!
2 of 2 people found this helpful.
on 11/24/2015 8:34:00 AM
More reviews by Glitterbear
Skin: Sensitive, Fair-Medium, Not Sure
Hair: Black, Straight, Medium
unfortunately, this smudges on me. got the brown one but it smudges until it becomes like an eye shadow at the end of the day.it also breaks very easily. becareful not to drop it on the flooe.
on 2/23/2015 10:04:00 PM
More reviews by peggy1234
Skin: Dry, Fair-Medium, Cool
Hair: Blond, Straight, Medium
Really love these!! I bought mine on amazon as they are hard to find in the US. Waterproof and eeeeasy to apply. Great colors. Cost like 10 bucks. Loooooove them! I love eye liners so I have tried very other one out there.
on 2/12/2015 9:44:00 AM
More reviews by saturninus
Skin: Combination, Fair, Cool
Hair: Brown, Wavy, Fine
Tested these against NYX, MUFE and Pixi and they are by far the most waterproof.
3 of 3 people found this helpful.
on 2/9/2015 4:18:00 AM
More reviews by vampaddict
Skin: Combination, Fair, Neutral
I purchased this eyeliner in two colors: #13. Bloody Sweet , #14. Bloody AngelThey are very long lasting, smudge-proof, and the colors are perfect.I'll definitely buy more colors soon.
on 1/8/2015 7:18:00 PM
More reviews by Geekwmakeup
Skin: Combination, Fair, Not Sure
Hair: Brunette, Other, Other
HG pencil eyeliners! I have in gold shine#12 and pastel #5. Soft, pigmented, gorgeous!! Also the price is ridiculously affordable! Can't wait to buy more!!!
on 9/29/2014 10:32:00 AM
More reviews by mybeautycravings
Hair: Black, Other, Other
This is my Holy Grail Pencil Eyeliner at the moment.Top 6 Reasons for Loving it1. 100% Smudge-proof2. Glides on Easily3. Looks Great4. No need for Sharpener5. Wipes off easily with cleanser6. Value-for MoneyCheck out full review, video and photos at http://bit.ly/1oHBj5H
Are you sure this product is discontinued?
daasfdsad, asdadasd, addasdasdas, asdasdasdasfsdfgdfs, fgdssdgfdgfg, gfgdgdfgdhfgj
Reviewer did not try the product Profanity/Vulgar language Advertising (Vendor promotion, iHerb Coupons etc.) Marketing campaign (BzzAgent, Influenster etc.)