Colorstay Smoky Shadow Stick

This product doesn't really deserve a long thorough review since it fell off the little pot the SECOND time I used it. The colors are really pigmented and easy to blend but it's not worth the hassle.

I bought this on a whim at the drugstore. It does provide good long-lasting coverage but the dual-end wand only allows you to use the tip of the product conveniently. After several uses the color pots fell out. Not worth the trouble in my opinion.

I have been looking for a brown shadow stick for everyday use, so I bought this in torch (brown/pink). The brown color is absolutely amazing! It is a perfect brown that is suitable for everyday wear. I can use this an eyeliner because it is so pigmented, and I also wear it on my lower lash line. The staying power is really great - I can wear it for 8 hours with no smudging or creasing at all …Read more

HORRIBLE PROUCT.
So disappointed.
i bought this at my local drugstore and the tips on both sides fell after 2 applications.
The gray color is a pretty dark gray color.but this lighter white side is not noticable.

I threw this away two days after purchasing.
DO NOT RECCOMEND.

I really like this product, however, I only ever use this as an eyeshadow base, like one would a NYX JEP pencil, but with less tugging. I have the 'torch' shade. I rub the pale colour all over my lid and into the crease, then gently smooth it over with my ring finger.If needed, the brown shade goes on the outer lid. I always pat some pressed eyeshadow(s) on top, HE or drugstore...with …Read more

I have the worst luck with eye shadow products - my eyes are set just right that 90% of eye shadows crease horribly within an hour or so. This product stays put, and can even serve as a way to hold other powder shadows on longer than they'd normally last. However, the stick inside the darker shade broke for me and fell out - not necessarily a problem, if mine hadn't landed in the …Read more

I got it from my friend as a present in Torch. I didn't think that it will work. But despite my expectations it has very nice colors and even almost doesn't crease.
The only thing which turned me down (one lippie off) is that the stick of a lighter shade fell out of the tube. I can put it back but if I turn it upside down it would fall out again. But I still can use it.. so …Read more

I have this double sided stick in 201 Torch - one side contains a champagne pink highlighting colour with a blunt, rounded end and the other a slightly sharpened dark brown, with warm, coppery specks.

A very big advantage of these is that they set and do not budge (though after about 2-3 hours I am experiencing a bit of nasty creasing) but before they set I am able to smear the …Read more

I bought the shadow stick in "Torch", which features a blunt ended pale, slightly shimmering highlight colour and a rich dark brown shaped end. The consistency of the product is lovely, very creamy and easy to apply but firm enough to make application controllable. The colours of this particular stick are decidedly neutral and can be used easily to create either a casual daytime look or …Read more

I purchased this on a whim since I had a CVS coupon not expecting much, but I'm pleasantly surprised. I have light brown hair, blue eyes, NW20 skin tone and the Torch shade works very well to bring out my eye colour. Don't expect loads of pigment. The light colour gives the lids some glimmer, and the cocoa-bronze works nicely as an eyeliner, but nothing like what you'd expect …Read more