Super Slim Eyeliner - Intense black

I have recently came back to using a black eyeliner and I was on a lookout for a not too expensive, reliable one with a sponge tip. L'Oreal used to do an absolutely genius one (it was a silver gold plastic screw on packaging and the product inside was brilliant but of course it was discontinued) so instead of going for my usual one of Clinique and Marc Jacobs (both are more glossy than this …Read more

This eyeliner transferred onto my eyelids within an hour. I don't have oily lids at all. If anything they are a tad dry. It also didn't glide smoothly across my eyelid. Now granted I am 48 so my eyelids are getting crepey but still I don't have this issue with other eyeliners. Just a bad product. Save your money.

Was just bad.
Smudged and was definitely not sweat or water resistant. Really nice dark pigment but just comes right off.
Id say this is the eyeliner they use in movies when the girl cries and her makeup goes everywhere!

I found this to be one of the better pen liners I've tried. I don't wear liner everyday, and I don't do a dramatic wingtip, but I found it went on easily enough. As some have pointed out the tip dries more quickly than the middle, but I store mine pen side down between uses and I start at the center (with the middle of the pen) so this hasn't been a problem for me …Read more

I had such high hopes for this eyeliner after 3 of my favourite beauty vloggers raved about it. Unfortunately, after giving it a chance and using it every day for a whole week, it just didn't work out for me.

The first couple of times I used it (I usually do winged eyeliner), it was easy to draw on the wing. However, by the third use, the product wouldn't flow to the very tip …Read more

I have purchased this twice. The pigmentation is good at first, but after a few months, the tip starts to lose color as compared to the body so it becomes hard to do a winged eye. When that happens, I don't use this for winged eye anymore. I put this on for the whole day and it does last. Although, there were definitely some smudges. For the price, the performance is okay.

I will …Read more

I like this liner almost as much as I like Stila Stay All-day thingy. I can't say it's a dupe because it doesn't stay put as long, but it's a great alternative if you're on budget. I'm currently on my 3rd pen today. I lost the first one in Thailand last year (I took this one with me because Stila is too precious), and repurchased again in Cambodia. It's …Read more

The first time applying, the product is amazing. The black is really black, is doesn't smudge or crack and the tip is super thin. However, after 3 times using this product, I couldn't get the pigmentation I had the first time I tried the product. There's still product left, but it's in the middle of the pen, this makes it hard and nearly impossible to get a super thin, winged …Read more

I love these liners, the precise lines that you can achieve are brilliant, the only thing I would say is that the pigmentation is lacking in comparison to many other drugstore liners.

This is the best liquid liner I've used. It's comparable to the Lancôme artliner but with a thinner tip and it smudges much more easily than the Lancôme one. It is awesome because the tip is thin but not too thin like the maybelline master precise so I can get a thin line or a thicker one. Very easy to use. Only downside is it smudges - mainly the wings of my liner.