Modern Pewter isn't exactly what I was expecting on my NW20 skin. It just doesn't make my brown eyes pop at all. It is pretty and all, but I was hoping for something a touch closer to the MAC Dalliance, UD Maui Wowie, or Too Faced Blonde Ambition (but sans all the glitter of the last two and bit less frosty than Dalliance). While the consistency and sheen is spot on to what I wanted. The color is much darker and more of a silver grey mixed in the greenish gold. Actually, "pewter" is a great description, but in the swatches I saw it looked more gold green and not such a heavy grey-ish tinge to it. I am assuming the swatches must have been on a more yellow based person. It is not ugly at all (and looks gorgeous with Dalliance), but it isn't what I wanted. I am debating if I will keep it. It feels like more of a fall/winter shade to me too. Oh well, the shadow quality itself feels nice.