5 months ago
This was the absolute WORST mascara I've ever used. I fished the tube out of the trash just to make sure I was reviewing the right Great Lash product, that's how much I hate this mascara. It started off a little clumpy but I was like "that's fine, I'll use a brush to separate the lashes, nbd, all mascaras are a little clumpy anyway..." It went downhill from there. At around the fifth use it had gone from a little clumpy to "Clump Extreme, now with extra clumps!". I had thick blobs of mascara matting up my lashes, but I was still able to comb them and improve the appearance a little so I kept using it. NEVER. AGAIN. About a week later I used it for the absolute last time. It was like trying to smear tar on my eyes, but it was the only mascara I had on me so I still went with it. The clumps dried so hard so quickly I wasn't able to break them into less hideous pieces with the comb. Worst of all, when I checked the mirror that afternoon I had a heavy swath of black powder and flakes under each eye. My makeup was very simple and natural that day, just foundation, lip gloss, a touch of concealer, and that blasted mascara, so I didn't get black eyeshadow all over the place and somehow fail to notice such a glaring mistake. The mascara just rained down like soot and left two heavy inky smudges under my eyes. I remember my mom using Maybelline in the pink and green tube back in the day and loving it. I've used it as recently as 2 years ago and loved it. What happened!?? Btw, not all mascaras are clumpy and thick. I recently received a tube of Tarte mascara in my BoxyCharm subscription box and it. was. amazing. No clumps, no lumps, no stickiness, just completely natural looking darkened lashes. I've literally NEVER used a mascara that wasn't at least a little lumpy. This Maybelline is going back in the trash now, and I'm probably never buying mascara from them again.
About reviewer (5 reviews)