NYX Professional Makeup Super Skinny & Super Fat Eye Marker

This stuff was so bad. There was absolutely no pigment. I dragged it across my eyelid and literally nothing came out.

I have the Super Fat Eye Marker, ergonomically I love it! The felt tip is easy to use-especially when applying on angles to achieve thickness. As for performance it falls short. The pigmentation is not there. Not very deep black but more of a granite tone. Doesn’t last long and i should note, it takes time to dry which leads to markings on the upper eyelid. I don’t think it’s a terrible product, it’s is promising, it just need some tweaking. It’s a good liner for the weekends quick errands out of the house, would not recommend with elaborate eye makeup...too risky.

Dried up so quickly and went from super black to Grey on less than 3 uses. I'm so disappointed coz it's hard to find a fat marker type liner. For the price, go for something else

i love this. it's so easy for you to just put on eyeliner everyday because it makes a thick line easily. you can also make a wing with it but you have to be careful

This was a huge disappointment. The super skinny marker was dry. I tried placing it cap down in hopes the ink would fill up the felt tip. But no success. I love NYX (who doesn't right?) but this was a letdown. I'll still to their amazing lip colours

Issa disappointment. No hate on the company, I love NYX to death. NYX is one of the higher end drugstore companies and I have always been impressed by their products... UNTIL NOW. This eyeliner is a joke. I splurged on it ($15 CAD at Shoppers Drugmart). I have hooded oily eyelids and have a hard time applying eyeliner. Now the design was great, applying the stuff was a breeze. I waited two minutes for it to dry, then opened my eyes. The liner immediately transferred onto my crease! I wiped it off and re-applied, this time waiting 5 minutes. THE SAME THING HAPPENED. I tried my second eye and the ink went gray. I bought this in "Carbon Black." After one application, it went dead. I had to hold it upside down for 10 minutes to get the ink flowing. One week later and it's dry.

So let's recap
- Doesn't dry on lids
- But dries in the marker
- Fades
- Smudges
- Expensive
- Not black

I tested this on my hand before purchasing and was impressed with the thin, dark line. After trying it on my eyes I was no longer impressed. I like a thin, dark line and wing on my eyes, and this product did not cut it. While it was quite easy to apply (the reason I gave it 2 stars instead 1), I found the line to be a pale grey colour if I use the tip. If I use the side of the marker it is darker, however that also makes it much too thick for my eye shape.

I purchased the thin marker and I was so excited to use it. It seemed like an easy product to start trying out eyeliner with, but boy was I wrong. I tried to apply it and barley any pigment came out. To get out a black looking color I had to push really hard and that made the line very thick, which I didn't want. The design of the pen was nice but there was barley any eyeliner in my eyeliner! Would not recommend to anyone!

i had to add to my previous review. i love the application-easy, no dragging and dark. after 10 hours of wear it has faded some, but i still like it.

I bought the Super Fat eye marker because I like a nice thick cat eye. Probably one of the worst eyeliners I have ever used. Dark gray, not black when applied. I have hooded eyelids and this would move and get all over the lid, making a super cute gray smudge all over the lid and whatever shadow I had put on. Did not wear longer than three hours, max. Like other reviewers have mentioned, the felt tip wears out and dries out as well. It's not a dupe for anything, and I'd probably only use this if I didn't know other eyeliners were better.